Scratching My Head: Solving a Puzzling Problem

  • Thread starter sahilmm15
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Head
8 replies · 2K views · last reply
sahilmm15
Messages
100
Reaction score
28
Homework Statement
The total number of 5 digit numbers of different digits in which the digit in the middle is the largest is ?
Relevant Equations
N/A
I am scratching my head on the problem but cannot figure out what to do. I tried in the following way:-
For (9)
_ _ _ _ _ . The middle place is fixed means only 1 way there. For the first place 9 ways (excluding 0) , second place (9 ways again because 9 digits are left excluding 9 and 0). Third place is the middle one which is already filled, fourth place 8 ways and last place 7 ways .

So total no of digits in which the digit in the middle is largest ( in this case it is 9 ) are 9*9*1*8*7. The same method would go for other numbers. Is my method correct or am I approaching the problem incorrectly?? I cannot find the answer.
 
After commenting on my method, Can you explain me why author has subtracted few terms in his method in the image below.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten notes on lined paper: a left-column method listing products for middle digits 9, 8, 7, 6 and 5, 4, 3 with 4 digits remaining; a note saying author's answer is the sum over n=4 to 9 of nP4; then the author's sum (4P4 - 3P3) + (5P4 - 4P3) + (6P4 - 5P3) + ... + (9P4 - 8P3).
    IMG_20201225_203247.jpg
    111.5 KB · Views: 212
sahilmm15 said:
After commenting on my method, Can you explain me why author has subtracted few terms in his method in the image below.
A five-digit number that starts with ##0## is only a four-digit number and doesn't count.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: sahilmm15
PeroK said:
A five-digit number that starts with ##0## is only a four-digit number and doesn't count.
I would interpret '5 digit numbers' to mean 'unique strings of length 5 each position of which is a decimal numeral', so that, with the 'middle digit is greatest' and 'digits are all different' constraints, the normally-lowest-sorting possibility would be 01423 and the normally-highest-sorting possibility would be 87965.
 
sysprog said:
I would interpret '5 digit numbers' to mean 'unique strings of length 5 each position of which is a decimal numeral', so that, with the 'middle digit is greatest' and 'digits are all different' constraints, the normally-lowest-sorting possibility would be 01423 and the normally-highest-sorting possibility would be 87965.
A number is a number and a string is a string. 01423 is a five-digit string but a four-digit number. In the same way that $$0x^2 + x + 1$$ is not a quadratic expression.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Vanadium 50 and sysprog
PeroK said:
A number is a number and a string is a string. 01423 is a five-digit string but a four-digit number. In the same way that $$0x^2 + x + 1$$ is not a quadratic expression.
I was thinking of pushbutton locks that have buttons that are numerally marked 0 through 9, which locks are such that until a reset button is pressed, it doesn't matter in which order or how many times the numerally-marked buttons are pressed ##\dots##
 
sahilmm15 said:
... of different digits ...

For (9)
_ _ _ _ _ . The middle place is fixed means only 1 way there. For the first place 9 ways
If the middle is 9, no others can be 9.
 
haruspex said:
If the middle is 9, no others can be 9.
Hmm 8 ways.