Self excited induction generators and grid connected solar inverters?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the integration of self-excited induction generators with grid-connected solar inverters, particularly in the context of using waste gas as fuel for an internal combustion engine driving an induction motor. Participants explore the feasibility of generating stable AC power that can be converted to DC for use with solar inverters, while addressing safety and regulatory concerns.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes a working grid-tied inverter system using waste flare gas and proposes improvements, such as using a single three-phase inverter instead of multiple single-phase units.
  • Another participant seeks clarification on the problem, emphasizing the need for stable direct current generation from a rotating machine driven by an internal combustion engine.
  • Concerns are raised about the excitation requirements for induction motors, with one participant suggesting that capacitive reactance may not be necessary if connected to the grid.
  • There is a discussion about the regulation of output voltage from a self-excited induction generator, with questions about how it can be maintained under varying conditions.
  • One participant clarifies that the output from the induction motor would be AC, and they seek advice on suitable capacitor connections for self-excitation.
  • Safety hazards related to stray capacitance when connecting to the grid are highlighted, with suggestions for using a grid-certified solar inverter to isolate the system.
  • A summary reiterates the lack of certified commercial wind inverters for constant voltage generation from standby generators, proposing self-excited induction motor generators as a potential solution.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express varying levels of understanding and interpretation of the problem, with no consensus on the best approach to self-excitation or the safety implications of the proposed system. Multiple competing views regarding the necessity of capacitive reactance and the regulation of output voltage remain unresolved.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the complexity of integrating self-excited induction generators with grid-connected systems, highlighting potential safety concerns and regulatory requirements that may affect implementation.

looking
Messages
57
Reaction score
6
TL;DR
No certified commercial grid connected wind inverters are readily available for constant voltage generation from conventional standby natural gas generators ( rectified to DC of course).....so maybe properly sized self excited induction motor generators would provide the constant current that grid connected solar inverters could handle.
OK I've developed a workable grid tied "wind" inverter, Certified, installed and successfully operating waste flare gas utility grid connected net metering system, with its associated functional usable space heating appreciated with todays -40 degree wind chills.
All this fully described within this forum In the past 5 years or so.

But surely increased generating capacity improvements can be made, such as using a single three phase inverter instead of three single phase inverters and transformers combined together, and maybe even using an a natural gas engine coupled to self excited common 3ph induction motor genset power end whose output would be compatible with ubiquitous solar inverters. Again mainly because 3 to 100 kw certified "wind" inverters just aren' even made anymore.
The three phase AC to DC rectification has already been fully tested and implemented with the existing working versions. Thus no new changes need to be made.

Now I know that asynchronous induction motors need a source of reactive power to even begin outputting the mechanical power of a coupled internal engine (or steam or wind or water or whatever) and the electrical grid would be almost an ideal source except for the most important matter of some once in a lifetime grid repairman safety issue.
So does anyone have a self excited stator connected capacitor solution that still produces a fairly voltage stable output. Currently I favor a stator connected wye connection capacitor network but don't know how many microfarads to try start testing. The initial test induction "motor" will be 20hp and the solar inverter 208v three phase to the grid.

Long story short. Spinning a 1740 rpm induction motor at a governed speed of about 1850 rpm will produce a constant current of about exactly the running amps of the induction motor if it were connected to a 3 phase grid.
I know the AC rectification to DC works.
Generator speed will be tightly controlled to within a few rpms.
If voltage and current output is stable, the the solar inverter should be being fed exactly what would keep it happy, I'd expect success, and extreme simplicity.

And I'll almost bet that an independent certifying agency like Intertec, and the electrical grid operator and associated inspectors will all be satisfied because the solar inverter addresses all their safety concerns of grid connection.
Or is there unanimous consent of electrical engineers that something serious is being overlooked. If so please speak up. Thanks
I'm certainly open to better ideas, and especially solutions that are orders of magnitude simpler, more efficient and less costly. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Engineering news on Phys.org
First, clearly specify the problem.
You have an IC engine, fuelled by waste gas. It will deliver shaft torque to a rotating machine, and you want that rotating machine, directly or indirectly, to generate a stable direct current, at high DC voltage, that appears to a type-approved grid-tie inverter, like a string of PV panels.
Is that correct ?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: hutchphd
I'm not completely clear on the task either. What caught my eye was spinning an induction motor at 1850 rpm while it is apparently hooked to the commercial power.
 
Averagesupernova said:
What caught my eye was spinning an induction motor at 1850 rpm while it is apparently hooked to the commercial power.
I interpreted the need for excitation capacitors, was because it was NOT grid connected, but a local energy supply, that could then be rectified for DC supply to the grid-tie inverter.

An induction generator, connected to the grid, does not need capacitive reactance to self-excite it, but I don't know the regulations regarding connection. Grid capacitance may be sufficient to self-excite them when there is a disconnect.

The RPM of a self-excited induction generator, is simply determined by resonance of the stator inductance, with the capacitive load. I think one question from above is; How is the output voltage of a self-excited induction generator regulated?
 
Baluncore said:
First, clearly specify the problem.
You have an IC engine, fuelled by waste gas. It will deliver shaft torque to a rotating machine, and you want that rotating machine, directly or indirectly, to generate a stable direct current, at high DC voltage, that appears to a type-approved grid-tie inverter, like a string of PV panels.
Is that correct ?
Yes... exactly except for your words "at high DC voltage". The voltage produced by the "rotating machine" would be AC and would be a characteristic of an "excited" induction motor driven at speeds a few percent faster than normal electric motor rpms, which makes them into an electrical generator. Any help as to delta stator winding connection of suitable capacitors etc would be appreciated. Stable nominal voltage and constant current from a 10 to 20 ish HP indiction generator is the objective.


If that is a clear answer the please don't read any of the following repetition. I do appreciate your time and past helpful knowledge. I also just made an edit on the stator capacitance since the connections should probably be "delta" instead of "wye".
Murray

FURTHER CLARIFICATION IF REQUIRED
IC engine fueled by waste gas, delivering torque to 208 voltage AC induction motor. Object is for this setup to " self excite" and produce power output when the IC engine speed is increased to cause the driven induction motor to act as a generator producing AC power.

Note that this IS a characteristic of any off the shelf 3 phase induction motor. As others have stated, if this IC engine/ induction motor setup were to be connected to a 60 cycle grid, everything would work perfectly when any nominal 1740 rpm induction motor was driven to about 1840 rpm, and the project objectives would be achieved.

HOWEVER THE PROJECT WOULD UTTERLY FAIL BECAUSE OF THE POSSIBILITY THAT SOME COMBINATION OF STRAY CAPICITANCE , IN SOME RARE INSTANCE COULD RESULT IN A SAFETY HAZARDS.

One solution to address that problem is to use any grid certified solar inverter in the setup, in order to totally isolate the IC driven/ induction motor generator from the grid.

Please note that the words DC have not yet been mentioned anywhere yet. DC comes in only because the grid connected "solar" inverter needs to be fed DC constant current. Trust me in saying that I know how to do that with a simple 3 phase rectifier that is proven to work, and will be acceptable to Intertec, electrical inspectors and the utility grid that this IC engine/induction generator/rectifier/ grid certified "solar" inverter will involve.

The above explanation is for the benefit of others.
My inquiry is for suggestions as to how to implement he self excitation of the IC engine/driven motor to produce the reactive power needed since the solar inverter is being used to totally safely isolate the power plant from the utility grid.
 
looking said:
TL;DR Summary: No certified commercial grid connected wind inverters are readily available for constant voltage generation from conventional standby natural gas generators ( rectified to DC of course).....so maybe properly sized self excited induction motor generators would provide the constant current that grid connected solar inverters could handle.

OK I've developed a workable grid tied "wind" inverter, Certified, installed and successfully operating waste flare gas utility grid connected net metering system, with its associated functional usable space heating appreciated with todays -40 degree wind chills.
All this fully described within this forum In the past 5 years or so.

But surely increased generating capacity improvements can be made, such as using a single three phase inverter instead of three single phase inverters and transformers combined together, and maybe even using an a natural gas engine coupled to self excited common 3ph induction motor genset power end whose output would be compatible with ubiquitous solar inverters. Again mainly because 3 to 100 kw certified "wind" inverters just aren' t even made anymore.
The three phase AC to DC rectification has already been fully tested and implemented with the existing working versions. Thus no new changes need to be made.

Now I know that asynchronous induction motors need a source of reactive power to even begin outputting the mechanical power of a coupled internal engine (or steam or wind or water or whatever) and the electrical grid would be almost an ideal source except for the most important matter of some once in a lifetime grid repairman safety issue.
So does anyone have a self excited stator connected capacitor solution that still produces a fairly voltage stable output. Currently I favor a stator connected delta connection capacitor network but don't know how many microfarads to try start testing. The initial test induction "motor" will be 20hp and the solar inverter 208v three phase to the grid.

Long story short. Spinning a 1740 rpm induction motor at a governed speed of about 1850 rpm will produce a constant current of about exactly the running amps of the induction motor if it were connected to a 3 phase grid.
I know the AC rectification to DC works.
Generator speed will be tightly controlled to within a few rpms.
If voltage and current output is stable, the the solar inverter should be being fed exactly what would keep it happy, I'd expect success, and extreme simplicity.

And I'll almost bet that an independent certifying agency like Intertec, and the electrical grid operator and associated inspectors will all be satisfied because the solar inverter addresses all their safety concerns of grid connection.
Or is there unanimous consent of electrical engineers that something serious is being overlooked. If so please speak up. Thanks
I'm certainly open to better ideas, and especially solutions that are orders of magnitude simpler, more efficient and less costly. Thanks.
 
Averagesupernova said:
I'm not completely clear on the task either. What caught my eye was spinning an induction motor at 1850 rpm while it is apparently hooked to the commercial power.
Connected Or hooked .... NO..but isolated by a grid certified inverter. ...yes
If only it could safely be directly connected, but that isn't an option AND ABSOLUTELY NO ONE SHOULD DO IT. It does make you wonder how a grid connected drag line or crane might potentially turn into an induction generator if the power source failed and the load turned a potential prime mover.
 
Baluncore said:
I interpreted the need for excitation capacitors, was because it was NOT grid connected, but a local energy supply, that could then be rectified for DC supply to the grid-tie inverter.

An induction generator, connected to the grid, does not need capacitive reactance to self-excite it, but I don't know the regulations regarding connection. Grid capacitance may be sufficient to self-excite them when there is a disconnect.

The RPM of a self-excited induction generator, is simply determined by resonance of the stator inductance, with the capacitive load. I think one question from above is; How is the output voltage of a self-excited induction generator regulated?
Agreed, all the way down to your last paragraph.

But then what are the apparatus and formula is needed to create the self-excited state for a particular 20 hp induction motor driven at a constant speed by a prime mover; and if the induction generated voltage is rectified and intrinsically stable when feeding into the constant current sink of say a solar inverter; then a solution has been achieved
 
looking said:
Yes... exactly except for your words "at high DC voltage". The voltage produced by the "rotating machine" would be AC and would be a characteristic of an "excited" induction motor driven at speeds a few percent faster than normal electric motor rpms, which makes them into an electrical generator.
You have constrained the generator to be an induction machine, indirectly generating DC by use of a rectifier. I allowed a dynamo or alternator to be considered, since the only requirement appears to be sufficient DC voltage to satisfy a grid-tie inverter.

looking said:
Any help as to delta stator winding connection of suitable capacitors etc would be appreciated. Stable nominal voltage and constant current from a 10 to 20 ish HP indiction generator is the objective.
Follow the standard procedure to select the excitation capacitors.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induction_generator#Example_application

In effect, you must overcompensate the IM inductance, to get a power factor greater than unity at the specified RPM and supply frequency. If you measure the IM current when free running, (easy), and when the rotor is physically locked, (be very quick), you can compute an estimate of the resistance and the inductance of the IM windings.

Be very careful.
High voltages can appear suddenly, when you least expect it.
 
  • #10
Baluncore said:
You have constrained the generator to be an induction machine, indirectly generating DC by use of a rectifier. I allowed a dynamo or alternator to be considered, since the only requirement appears to be sufficient DC voltage to satisfy a grid-tie inverter.


Follow the standard procedure to select the excitation capacitors.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induction_generator#Example_application

In effect, you must overcompensate the IM inductance, to get a power factor greater than unity at the specified RPM and supply frequency. If you measure the IM current when free running, (easy), and when the rotor is physically locked, (be very quick), you can compute an estimate of the resistance and the inductance of the IM windings.

Be very careful.
High voltages can appear suddenly, when you least expect it.
Excellent. The only reason I would prefer an induction generator is that there are 30 to 100 horse power "induction motors" available at even no cost.
THANKS for the link.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
6K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
6K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
9K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
5K
Replies
24
Views
5K