Shaft system for a bevel gear reducer

  • Topic: Engineering 
  • Thread starter jojosg
  • Start date
7 replies · 657 views · last reply
jojosg
Messages
43
Reaction score
5
Homework Statement
The following figure shows a shaft system used in bevel-gear reducer. Given condition: mean diameter of pitch circle dm=30mm, Ft=1300N, Fr=400N, Fa=250N, n=14300r/min, af=1.5. please evaluate the bearing lifespan, where the bearing 30305 is used. Please also give explain the meaning of bearing designation 30305. (For Bearing used C=43200N, e=0.37, if Fa/Fr < e, X = 1, Y = 0; if Fa/Fr > e, X=0.4, Y=1.6, Fi=Fr/(2Y))
Relevant Equations
Bearing designation definition: 30305
[tex]
\text{3: Tapered roller bearing; 03: dimension series; 05: bore } d=5\times5=25\ \mathrm{mm}
[/tex]

Equivalent dynamic load:
[tex]
P = a_f\left(XF_r + YF_a\right)
[/tex]

Induced thrust:
[tex]
F_i = \frac{F_r}{2Y}
[/tex]

Bearing life in hours:
[tex]
L_{10,\mathrm{h}}=\frac{10^6}{60,n}\left(\frac{C}{P}\right)^p
[/tex]
For roller bearings, [itex]p=10/3[/itex].
Free-body diagram of a shaft with bearings 1 and 2 on the left, a bevel gear on the right, and dimensions 100 and 50 along the shaft and 30 vertically. Forces shown are FA, FT and FR at the gear.

I need to evaluate bearing life and explain the meaning of bearing designation 30305. I am not confident with my axial force balance step.
First, calculate resultant radial loads on bearing 1 and bearing 2.Vertical plane moment balance:[tex]F_{r2,v} = \frac{(F_t+F_r)\cdot 150}{100} = \frac{(1300+400)\cdot 150}{100}=2550\ \mathrm{N}[/tex][tex]F_{r1,v} = 1300+400 - 2550 = 850\ \mathrm{N}[/tex]

Horizontal plane, axial force creates bending moment [itex]M=F_a\cdot d_m/2 = 250 \times 15 = 3750\ \mathrm{N\cdot mm}[/itex][tex]F_{r2,h}=\frac{F_r\cdot 150 + 3750}{100}=637.5\ \mathrm{N}[/tex][tex]F_{r1,h}=|400 - 637.5|=237.5\ \mathrm{N}[/tex]

Resultant radial loads:[tex]F_{r1}=\sqrt{F_{r1,v}^2+F_{r1,h}^2}=\sqrt{850^2+237.5^2}=882.5\ \mathrm{N}[/tex][tex]F_{r2}=\sqrt{F_{r2,v}^2+F_{r2,h}^2}=\sqrt{2550^2+637.5^2}=2628.4\ \mathrm{N}[/tex]

Induced thrusts, using [itex]Y=1.6[/itex]:[tex]F_{i1}=\frac{F_{r1}}{2Y}=\frac{882.5}{2\times1.6}=275.78\ \mathrm{N}[/tex][tex]F_{i2}=\frac{F_{r2}}{2Y}=\frac{2628.4}{2\times1.6}=821.38\ \mathrm{N}[/tex]

Axial balance check:[itex]F_{i2}+F_a = 821.38 + 250 = 1071.38 > F_{i1}[/itex]So:[tex]F_{a1}=F_{i2}+F_a=1071.38\ \mathrm{N},\quad F_{a2}=F_{i2}=821.38\ \mathrm{N}[/tex]

Check ratios against [itex]e=0.37[/itex]:[tex]\frac{F_{a1}}{F_{r1}}=\frac{1071.38}{882.5}=1.214>0.37 \implies X_1=0.4,;Y_1=1.6[/tex][tex]\frac{F_{a2}}{F_{r2}}=\frac{821.38}{2628.4}=0.312<0.37 \implies X_2=1,;Y_2=0[/tex]

Equivalent loads:[tex]P_1 = a_f\left(X_1F_{r1}+Y_1F_{a1}\right)=1.5\left(0.4\times 882.5 + 1.6\times 1071.38\right)=3045.4\ \mathrm{N}[/tex][tex]P_2 = a_f\left(X_2F_{r2}+Y_2F_{a2}\right)=1.5\left(1\times 2628.4 + 0\right)=3942.6\ \mathrm{N}[/tex]Since [itex]P_2>P_2[/itex], Bearing 2 governs life.

[tex]L_{10,\mathrm{h}}=\frac{10^6}{60\times 14300}\left(\frac{43200}{3942.6}\right)^{10/3}[/tex]

My uncertainty:I’m not fully confident in the horizontal plane moment calculation from the bevel gear axial force, and also unsure whether my axial thrust balance direction is correct for this opposed tapered roller pair. Could you verify?
 
You have some mistakes. Let's start with your free body diagrams of the axle loading in each plane, can you produce them?
 
1) There should be three (not two), and one should have a moment in addition to the reaction forces acting on it (the axle).

2)Why does ##F_A## have two orthogonal components in the top diagram ( it should be an axial load for that plane) and you've flipped the direction of the axial force from the accompanying problem diagram?

Let's just do one for now. Imagine you are looking the plane shown in the original diagram. Show the FBD of the axle for that plane including forces and moments.
 
Last edited:
erobz said:
1) There should be three (not two), and one should have a moment in addition to the reaction forces acting on it (the axle).

2)Why does ##F_A## have two orthogonal components in the top diagram ( it should be an axial load for that plane) and you've flipped the direction of the axial force from the accompanying problem diagram?

Let's just do one for now. Imagine you are looking the plane shown in the original diagram. Show the FBD of the axle for that plane including forces and moments.
Picture1.webp

Like this?
 
jojosg said:
better( still not quite right); it is not an internal moment. The moment is an external moment ( that means it's an external load on the axle ). You don't flip the direction or handedness of known external loads when analyzing the beam. You seem to be confused on that point, perhaps thinking that you are looking at internal moments/forces?

Think about which way ##F_A## bends(rotates) the beam, and which your applied ( effective moment load from ##F_A##) external moment bends (rotates) the beam. Does the latter match the former?

Edit: I'm going to help you out here, if you don't understand why the diagram is this way please say something. This is the effective loading on the shaft in the ##xy## plane.

1795206396265.webp


Use ## \sum F_y = 0 ## and ##\sum M_p = 0## to determine the vertical reactions. We'll go from there.
 
Last edited:
erobz said:
better( still not quite right); it is not an internal moment. The moment is an external moment ( that means it's an external load on the axle ). You don't flip the direction or handedness of known external loads when analyzing the beam. You seem to be confused on that point, perhaps thinking that you are looking at internal moments/forces?

Think about which way ##F_A## bends(rotates) the beam, and which your applied ( effective moment load from ##F_A##) external moment bends (rotates) the beam. Does the latter match the former?

Edit: I'm going to help you out here, if you don't understand why the diagram is this way please say something. This is the effective loading on the shaft in the ##xy## plane.

View attachment 375473

Use ## \sum F_y = 0 ## and ##\sum M_p = 0## to determine the vertical reactions. We'll go from there.

Given data
[itex]d_m=30\ \text{mm},\ F_t=1300\ \text{N},\ F_r=400\ \text{N},\ F_a=250\ \text{N},\ n=14300\ \text{rpm},\ a_f=1.5,\ C=43200\ \text{N},\ e=0.37,\ X=0.4,\ Y=1.6\ (F_a/F_r>e),\ p=10/3[/itex]

1. Plane reactions
Tangential plane ([itex]F_t[/itex]):
[tex]\sum M_1 = 0 \Rightarrow R_{2t}(100) - 1300(150) = 0 \Rightarrow R_{2t} = 1950\ \text{N}[/tex]
[tex]\sum F_y = 0 \Rightarrow R_{1t} = -650\ \text{N}[/tex]

Radial plane ([itex]F_r + \text{offset moment from }F_a[/itex]):
[tex]M = F_a \cdot 30 = 7500\ \text{N·mm}[/tex]
[tex]\sum M_1 = 0 \Rightarrow R_{2r}(100) - 400(150) - 7500 = 0 \Rightarrow R_{2r}=675\ \text{N}[/tex]
[tex]\sum F_y = 0 \Rightarrow R_{1r} = -275\ \text{N}[/tex]

Resultant radial loads:
[tex]F_{r1} = \sqrt{R_{1t}^2 + R_{1r}^2} = 705.78\ \text{N}[/tex]
[tex]F_{r2} = \sqrt{R_{2t}^2 + R_{2r}^2} = 2063.52\ \text{N}[/tex]

2. Induced axial thrusts
[tex]F_i = \frac{F_r}{2Y}[/tex]
[tex]F_{i1}=220.56\ \text{N}[/tex]
[tex]F_{i2}=644.85\ \text{N}[/tex]
Opposed bearing arrangement, assumed external thrust carried by bearing 1:
[tex]F_{a1}=F_{i2}+F_a=894.85\ \text{N}[/tex]
[tex]F_{a2}=0[/tex]

3. Equivalent dynamic loads
Bearing 1: [itex]F_{a1}/F_{r1}=1.268>e[/itex]
[tex]P_1 = XF_{r1}+YF_{a1}=1714.07\ \text{N}[/tex]
Bearing 2: [itex]F_{a2}/F_{r2}=0<e[/itex]
[tex]P_2 = F_{r2}=2063.52\ \text{N}[/tex]
With application factor:
[tex]P_{d1}=a_f P_1=2571.11\ \text{N}[/tex]
[tex]P_{d2}=a_f P_2=3095.28\ \text{N}[/tex]

4. [itex]L_{10}[/itex] life (Shigley)
[tex]L_{10} = \left(\frac{C}{P_d}\right)^p 10^6\ \text{rev}[/tex]
[tex]L_{10h} = \frac{L_{10}}{60n}[/tex]
[tex]L_{10h,1}\approx 14160\ \text{h}[/tex]
[tex]\boxed{L_{10h,2}\approx 7629\ \text{h}}[/tex]
Bearing 2 governs the system life.

5. Bearing designation 30305
3 = tapered roller bearing; 03 = dimension series; 05 = bore code, bore = 25 mm.

My question:
Is my axial thrust balance correct? I assumed [itex]F_{a1}=F_{i2}+F_a[/itex] for the opposed mounting.


This is my understanding.
 
Last edited:
jojosg said:
Given data
[itex]d_m=30\ \text{mm},\ F_t=1300\ \text{N},\ F_r=400\ \text{N},\ F_a=250\ \text{N},\ n=14300\ \text{rpm},\ a_f=1.5,\ C=43200\ \text{N},\ e=0.37,\ X=0.4,\ Y=1.6\ (F_a/F_r>e),\ p=10/3[/itex]



Radial plane ([itex]F_r + \text{offset moment from }F_a[/itex]):
[tex]M = F_a \cdot 30 = 7500\ \text{N·mm}[/tex]
[tex]\sum M_1 = 0 \Rightarrow R_{2r}(100) - 400(150) - 7500 = 0 \Rightarrow R_{2r}=675\ \text{N}[/tex]
[tex]\sum F_y = 0 \Rightarrow R_{1r} = -275\ \text{N}[/tex]
Slow down.

1) You don't seem to understand the direction of the effective load from the axial force. !This is important! What is the direction of the moment from ##F_A##? You are getting the wrong reaction forces because of this misunderstanding. This kind of thing is fundamentally bad...the kind of misunderstanding that will haunt you. Talk to me about what your line of thought is here so we can fix the misconception.

2) Clarify this with your prof. The pitch Diameter is given as 30 mm in the problem statement. However, the drawing shows the pitch Radius as 30 mm. So which is correct?
 
Last edited: