Shopping Carts, Finding Horizontal Force

2 replies · 14K views · last reply
physics114
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Correct? Please let me know if my logic is off.

Given Problem
A shopper pushes a 6.1 kg shopping cart up a 13° incline, as shown in the figure. Find the magnitude of the horizontal force, F, needed to give the cart an acceleration of 1.51 m/s2.
Cartoon of a shopper pushing a shopping cart up a ramp inclined at 13 degrees, with a red horizontal arrow labelled F at the hands and a purple arrow labelled a pointing along the cart's direction of motion.


Relevant equations
F = ma
Fy = F1cos13°
Fx = F1sin13°
Free-body diagram of a force F acting horizontally on a cart at the origin of x and y axes, with the incline direction a at angle 13 degrees, labelled Fy = F1cos13° and Fx = F1sin13°.


Attempted Solution
Given acceleration as 1.51m/s2, I found the net force (?)

F = ma
F = (6.1kg) * (1.51m/s2)
F = 9.211 N

Since the problem is asking for the horizontal force, I would only be focusing on the F1,x direction. With this i would use the F`,x = F1sin13° formula (?)

Use this force found earlier with Newton's Second Law to find the force in the horizontal direction.

F1,x = F1sin13°
F1 = F1,x / sin13°
F1 = 9.211N / sin13°
F1 = 40.9467 N

ADJUSTMENT 1:
Calculated with Fx = Fcos13° instead of Fsin13°
F1 = (9.121 N) / (cos13°)
F1 = 9.35989N
Answer is still incorrect. The website tells me:
"Your response differs from the correct answer by more than 10%. Double check your calculations"
 
Last edited:
This problem is easier if you rotate your axis 13 degrees. So draw the x-axis to be parallel with the acceleration. With your current axis ... Fx = F
and don't forget your normal force and force due to gravity.Now, if you redraw your axis along the direction of acceleration
Fx = Fcos(13) -mg sin(13) = ma

So now the answer is trivial algebra
F = [m(a+g sin(13))] / cos(13)
 
Last edited: