Should I Upgrade Graduate Certificate Into Second Masters Degree?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the decision of whether to upgrade a Graduate Certificate in Systems Engineering to a full Master's degree. Participants explore the implications of this decision on career advancement, job market perceptions, and the value of additional degrees in engineering fields.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Exploratory

Main Points Raised

  • One participant questions whether completing the degree would lead to a raise or expanded job responsibilities, suggesting that in their experience, work experience and knowledge are more critical than additional degrees.
  • Another participant notes that they have not seen job postings that require two Master's degrees, raising the question of the necessity of obtaining a second Master's in Systems Engineering.
  • Some participants suggest that a second Master's may be beneficial if one intends to shift career directions, such as moving from technical roles to management or business positions.
  • A participant shares a personal experience where despite having extensive experience, they were not considered for a position due to not holding a specific degree, illustrating the potential importance of degree requirements in hiring processes.
  • There is a discussion about the flexibility of job postings, with some suggesting that having an MS in Electrical Engineering may suffice for roles that also accept an MS in Systems Engineering, depending on the wording of job requirements.
  • One participant emphasizes that since the company would cover the costs, the decision should weigh the value of time spent on the second Master's against other potential activities.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the value of obtaining a second Master's degree, with some questioning its necessity while others acknowledge potential benefits depending on career goals. The discussion remains unresolved regarding whether the additional degree would significantly impact career advancement.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight limitations such as the specific job market dynamics in engineering and the variability in hiring practices across different companies and roles. There are also concerns about the expiration of credits from the Graduate Certificate and the implications for pursuing the Master's degree.

YoshiMoshi
Messages
233
Reaction score
10
I have two Electrical Engineering Degrees, Bachelor of Science and a Master of Engineering.
I'm almost done with a Graduate Certificate in Systems Engineering. Which is 4 classes.

I can upgrade the Graduate Certificate in Systems Engineering to a full blown masters (10 classes). Should I? My company would pay for most of it. It's hard to turn down free stuff.

Food for thought:
  1. I would need to take an additional 6 classes, 4 systems engineering, 1 project management, 1 graduate math class, to upgrade the certificate to a degree
  2. I already took a project management class and graduate math class at another university when I earned my first Masters degree. Because it was more than 6 years ago, I can't transfer the credits over from the first masters to a second masters. My current university does not allow credit by examination for graduate classes. So I can't "test out" of these two classes. So I would have to take these two classes again a second time, despite getting excellent grades from the first time I took them. I'm 110 % against retaking classes I got As in just because it was more than 6 years ago.
  3. Once the classes from my graduate certificate are more than 6 years old, they "expire". Meaning I won't be able to pursue the masters degree without retaking the 4 classes from the certificate because they would be "expired". Despite getting good grades.
I work in industry as an electrical systems engineer. Should I upgrade a systems engineering graduate certificate to a masters degree? I already have a bachelors and masters in electrical. Would getting two masters degree help my career as an engineer? I have to make a decision soon.

Thanks for any help in academic advising!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Would completing this degree mean you would probably get a raise in your current position? An expanded job assignment with a corresponding raise?
YoshiMoshi said:
Would getting two masters degree help my career as an engineer?
When you look at job openings at other companies, does it seem like the extra degree will make a difference? At least in my line of work as an EE (R&D on embedded systems), once you have the basic degrees, your work experience and knowledge (tested in interviews) matter the most.
 
berkeman said:
Would completing this degree mean you would probably get a raise in your current position? An expanded job assignment with a corresponding raise?

When you look at job openings at other companies, does it seem like the extra degree will make a difference? At least in my line of work as an EE (R&D on embedded systems), once you have the basic degrees, your work experience and knowledge (tested in interviews) matter the most.
In my case, no, not in my current position. I wouldn't get a penny raise. When I look at job postings at other companies, I haven't come across a single one that mentions two master degrees.

Why do people get two master degrees?
 
YoshiMoshi said:
In my case, no, not in my current position. I wouldn't get a penny raise. When I look at job postings at other companies, I haven't come across a single one that mentions two master degrees.

Why do people get two master degrees?
No, you look for posts that read "MS EE required" and posts that separately read "MS Systems Engineering required." And see whether the number of posts in the second category would justify spending the time in getting a MS Systems Engineering.[ETA: Longer Answer]

* Sometimes a second master’s is useful if you shift directions in your career. For example, if you have a MS EE and are content doing hands-on technical work, you’re fine with the single degree. But if you later want to switch away from hands-on technical work, and migrate towards management or business roles, then getting an MBA may help advance your career.

* With respect to degrees in two separate technical fields, that depends strongly on how flexible hiring managers are in your particular fields of interest. You’ll often hear the advice: “Once you’ve worked for X years, it’s your track record that matters, not your degree.” That’s true to a certain extent, but not completely. I’ve cited my own personal example before: I have a PhD Physics. And I have had a lot of experience in designing and building complex mechanical apparatus. At one time, a recruiter (who had worked with me before) approached me for a position as a patent agent for a client primarily involved with mechanical inventions. At the time I already had a well-established track record as a patent agent. The recruiter thought I’d be a good fit, and forwarded my resume to the client. But the client responded, “Candidate must have a BS ME.” So even though I had probably more mechanical engineering experience than a fresh BS ME, even though I had a well-established track record as a patent agent, and even though my recruiter was pushing to have the client at least talk to me, the client held firm on the degree requirement, and wouldn’t even consider me. But, since I had plenty of other prospects, I felt no need whatsoever to get a BS ME. :wink:

* In your case, you have an MS EE and are working as an electrical systems engineer. If you wanted to (or had to) find a systems engineering job at another company, you’ll be fine as long as the job posts don’t specify “MS Systems Engineering required”. If they specify something more flexible along the lines of “MS EE or MS Systems Engineering preferred. Candidates with other degrees having appropriate experience will be considered.”, you’re OK.

* In your specific case, since your company is willing to foot the bill for the second master's, cost is not a consideration. The question then is your time. The second master's certainly won’t do any harm, and might help (and learning new stuff can be an end in itself, even if review of some previous material is involved). The question then is, "What other activity would you spend your time on, if you don’t pursue the second master's?" And it doesn’t have to involve professional advancement, just something satisfying and of value to you.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: YoshiMoshi

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 50 ·
2
Replies
50
Views
11K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
5K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
1K