caliban07
- 19
- 0
What would be the reducing reaction for these in water?
The discussion revolves around the reducing properties of sodium dithionite in relation to ammonia (NH3) and its conversion to ammonium (NH4) in water. Participants explore the implications of using reducing agents in water conditioning, particularly for aquatic environments, and seek to understand the chemical processes involved.
Participants express varying levels of understanding and curiosity about the chemistry involved, with no clear consensus on the specifics of how sodium dithionite and related compounds function as reducing agents in this context. There are multiple competing views regarding the implications of ammonia and ammonium toxicity in aquatic environments.
Participants note that the redox chemistry of ammonia/ammonium is complex and often influenced by external factors such as bacterial activity and solution pH, which remain unresolved in the discussion.
"Non-toxic?" Depends on "context" and the anion (you don't find single ionic species in solution --- I'm reasonably certain you know that), nitrate and/or nitrite are blamed for "blue babies," just about any ammonium salts are implicated in gouty arthritis. Free ammonia in solution implies fairly high pH which is trouble for most aquatic beasties. Phosphoric acid is (if memory serves) the usual additive for dropping pH in aquaria. Bottom line, there's not a whole lot of redox chemistry for ammonia/ammonium in aquaria that does not involve bacterial activity to generate nitrite and nitrate.caliban07 said:nh3 to it's non toxic ionised state nh4
caliban07 said:I'm not a scientist I am just seeking some basic info on how reducing agents work.
Bystander said:"Non-toxic?" Depends on "context" and the anion (you don't find single ionic species in solution --- I'm reasonably certain you know that), nitrate and/or nitrite are blamed for "blue babies," just about any ammonium salts are implicated in gouty arthritis. Free ammonia in solution implies fairly high pH which is trouble for most aquatic beasties. Phosphoric acid is (if memory serves) the usual additive for dropping pH in aquaria. Bottom line, there's not a whole lot of redox chemistry for ammonia/ammonium in aquaria that does not involve bacterial activity to generate nitrite and nitrate.Oxidizers remove electrons (or accept electrons --- difference between armed robbery and a bribe) from other chemical species and are reduced in the process. Reducing agents give up electrons to other chemical compounds, and are in the process oxidized.
Some chemicals, families of chemicals, have many oxidation states, others have only one or two. Dithionate is one of many states for sulfur. The family tree runs from sulfide (-2) through sulfate (+6) to peroxydisulfate (+7?), and there are literally more than a dozen steps along the way, thiosulfate, dithionate that take a scorecard for me to keep track of.