Solution Attached: Download Now!

  • Thread starter Thread starter dorothy
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Kinematic
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the accuracy of answers to a set of physics questions, particularly focusing on question 3, which is deemed incorrect by multiple participants. The average speed is clarified as 11.7 m/s, contrasting with average velocity, which is incorrectly calculated by some. Participants express confusion over the distinction between speed and velocity, emphasizing the need for clarity in the questions. There is also criticism regarding the structure of question 1, suggesting that identical answer pairs may mislead respondents. Overall, the conversation highlights the importance of understanding fundamental physics concepts and the clarity of exam questions.
dorothy
Messages
39
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
Hi everyone, because I am on vacation right now. So, I'm prepping for the topic of kinematics. I've done some exercises(not homework or graded assignments!!) , but since the teacher hasn't taught it yet, I don't know if the answers are right, so I hope someone here can help me check the answers. Thanks! ☺️
Relevant Equations
v = u+at
s = ut + 1/2 at ^2
v^2 = u^2+2as
The attached pdf is my solution. Thank you!

1649702357362.png
 

Attachments

Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
All the answers for question 3 are wrong.
 
mjc123 said:
All the answers for question 3 are wrong.

I think so coz I found the avg. velocity to be 11.7 .
Except Q3, do I get the questions(question1-30) all correct? thanks
 
No, that is the average speed.
I didn't look at all the questions.
 
dorothy said:
I think so coz I found the avg. velocity to be 11.7 .
Except Q3, do I get the questions(question1-30) all correct? thanks
Question 3 should be asking for the average speed.
 
dorothy said:
I think so coz I found the avg. velocity to be 11.7 .
Except Q3, do I get the questions(question1-30) all correct? thanks
The average speed is 11.7 m/s, not the average velocity. Do you know the difference between the two? Question 1 supposedly tests whether you do.

Aside from that, I wonder why the choices in the two parts of question 1 come in identical pairs. I suppose this makes it more likely to get the right answer by flipping a coin.
 
kuruman said:
The average speed is 11.7 m/s, not the average velocity. Do you know the difference between the two? Question 1 supposedly tests whether you do.

Aside from that, I wonder why the choices in the two parts of question 1 come in identical pairs. I suppose this makes it more likely to get the right answer by flipping a coin.
for Q3, it should be ''avg. velocity: [(5)(-20)÷2 +(2+7)(20)÷2]÷12 = 3.3 m/s'', right?
 
kuruman said:
The average speed is 11.7 m/s, not the average velocity. Do you know the difference between the two? Question 1 supposedly tests whether you do.

Aside from that, I wonder why the choices in the two parts of question 1 come in identical pairs. I suppose this makes it more likely to get the right answer by flipping a coin.
Besides Q3, do I get all correct in Q1-Q30? thanks
 
dorothy said:
for Q3, it should be ''avg. velocity: [(5)(-20)÷2 +(2+7)(20)÷2]÷12 = 3.3 m/s'', right?
That's okay, but it's not a good way to write things. You ought to explicitly mention the (signed) area under the graph and the total time.

I would also have a criticism of these questions. It would make much more sense to me to calculate the displacement at ##t= 12 \ s##. That's the key point. Also, that at ##t = 10 \ s## the object is back where it was at ##t = 0 \ s##.

IMO, that's the sort of information that it's important to get from a graph like that.
 
  • #10
PeroK said:
That's okay, but it's not a good way to write things. You ought to explicitly mention the (signed) area under the graph and the total time.

I would also have a criticism of these questions. It would make much more sense to me to calculate the displacement at ##t= 12 \ s##. That's the key point. Also, that at ##t = 10 \ s## the object is back where it was at ##t = 0 \ s##.

IMO, that's the sort of information that it's important to get from a graph like that.
i see , thanks
 
  • #11
dorothy said:
Besides Q3, do I get all correct in Q1-Q30? thanks
I can only speak for myself when I say that I am disinclined to go over all 30 of these questions, find the answers to all and then report back which are correct and which are not. If you have difficulties with a specific question, please post it stating why you answered it the way you did and I will be happy to help you.
 
  • Like
Likes nasu, PeroK, gmax137 and 1 other person
  • #12
kuruman said:
I can only speak for myself when I say that I am disinclined to go over all 30 of these questions, find the answers to all and then report back which are correct and which are not. If you have difficulties with a specific question, please post it stating why you answered it the way you did and I will be happy to help you.
I’m sorry. May I know whether my ans is correct or not? I think (1) & (3) are wrong because velocity and acceleration get direction(vectors) while speed doesn’t(scalar). Thank you.
 

Attachments

  • 57B00410-57F0-41BC-B38A-720FC76401E0.jpeg
    57B00410-57F0-41BC-B38A-720FC76401E0.jpeg
    16.6 KB · Views: 100
  • #13
kuruman said:
I can only speak for myself when I say that I am disinclined to go over all 30 of these questions, find the answers to all and then report back which are correct and which are not. If you have difficulties with a specific question, please post it stating why you answered it the way you did and I will be happy to help you.
I would like to ask Q19 as well. Thanks.
(2) is correct because A&B have the same total displacement and they finish it with the same time 10s so the two objects have the same avg. velocity.

(3) is correct because at t=1s, the slope of A is greater than the slope of B, which means A has a greater acceleration than B at t=1s.
 

Attachments

  • 1159393B-72CB-4566-B6C7-D65E9E0E5075.jpeg
    1159393B-72CB-4566-B6C7-D65E9E0E5075.jpeg
    42.5 KB · Views: 102
  • #14
dorothy said:
I’m sorry. May I know whether my ans is correct or not? I think (1) & (3) are wrong because velocity and acceleration get direction(vectors) while speed doesn’t(scalar). Thank you.
Your reasoning is incorrect. The easiest way to show that a statement is incorrect is by providing counterexamples.
1. An object moving at constant velocity must have constant speed. This asserts that ALL objects moving at constant velocities have constant speed. To argue that this is incorrect, you must provide an example of an object moving at constant velocity the speed of which is clearly changing with time. Can you think of one? If you can, then the statement is false.
2. An object with zero velocity can be accelerating. Unlike the previous statement this asserts that an object with zero velocity may or may not be accelerating. Can you provide an example where an object with zero velocity IS NOT accelerating and another example where an object with zero velocity IS accelerating? If you can, then the statement is true.
3. An object moving with a constant speed must have zero acceleration. This asserts that ALL objects moving at constant speed have zero acceleration. To argue that this is incorrect, you must provide an example of an object that moves at constant speed the acceleration of which is clearly not zero. Can you think of one? If you can, then the statement is false.
 
  • Like
Likes PeroK
  • #15
dorothy said:
I would like to ask Q19 as well. Thanks.
(2) is correct because A&B have the same total displacement and they finish it with the same time 10s so the two objects have the same avg. velocity.

(3) is correct because at t=1s, the slope of A is greater than the slope of B, which means A has a greater acceleration than B at t=1s.
Your reasoning is correct here. Why do you think that choice 1 is incorrect? What is your argument that the two objects do not meet at t = 5 s?
 
  • #16
kuruman said:
Your reasoning is correct here. Why do you think that choice 1 is incorrect? What is your argument that the two objects do not meet at t = 5 s?
coz their displacement are not equal
 
  • #17
dorothy said:
coz their displacement are not equal
I don't disagree with you, but what evidence do you have to support your assertion? As a beginner, you must get into the habit of supporting your assertions using the evidence that you are given.

So what is the evidence that the displacements are different?
 
  • #18
kuruman said:
I don't disagree with you, but what evidence do you have to support your assertion? As a beginner, you must get into the habit of supporting your assertions using the evidence that you are given.

So what is the evidence that the displacements are different?
since the area of A from t=0s to t=5s and the area of B from t=0s to t=5s are different.
 
Back
Top