Solve Definite Integrals: F(x)=0.5x2-2 & F(x)=x3+x2-6x

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around the evaluation of definite integrals for the functions F(x) = 0.5x² - 2 and F(x) = x³ + x² - 6x, specifically focusing on finding the area between these functions over the interval from -2 to 2.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the concept of definite integrals and their relation to area, questioning how to handle regions where the function is below the x-axis. There are attempts to calculate areas for both functions, with some confusion regarding the interpretation of positive and negative areas.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided calculations and interpretations of the areas under the curves, while others have raised questions about the integration process and the use of absolute values in integrals. There is an ongoing exploration of how to correctly evaluate the definite integrals and understand the implications of the results.

Contextual Notes

Participants note discrepancies between manual calculations and calculator results, indicating potential misunderstandings in the integration process. There is also mention of specific integral properties and their interpretations, which are being clarified throughout the discussion.

Sirsh
Messages
262
Reaction score
10
Hi all, just wondering if someone could explain to me about define integrals.
Say i have F(x)=0.5x2-2 and F(x)=x3+x2-6x and i want to find the area of the regions which is satisfied from -2 to 2.

so [tex]\int[/tex]0.5x2-2 from -2 to 2. [tex]\int[/tex]x3+x2-6x from -2 to 2.

Now with the cubic, from -2 to 0 is supposedly positive and from 0 to 2 it's negative, is that true i thought the it doesn't matter which region the area is in it'll always be counted as positive.

so, [tex]\int[/tex]x3+x2-6x from -2 to 0. = [tex]\int[/tex](-2)3+(-2)2-6(-2) - [tex]\int[/tex](0)3+(0)2-6(0) = 8-0 = 8units2


[tex]\int[/tex]x3+x2-6x from 0 to 2. = [tex]\int[/tex](0)3+(0)2-6(0) - [tex]\int[/tex](2)3+(2)2-6(2) = 0- 0 = 0 units2

Therefore, Area from (-2 to 0)+ Area from (0 to 2) = 8+0 = 8units2

But using my calculator doing the same steps (except in the graphing section) doing -2 to 0 and adding it to 0 to 2's value i get 16units2( 10.667+5.333)

I don't know what's going on..
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I only did the one area for the 2nd function, ignore the 1st function.
 
A definite integral is positive if the area is above the y-axis and negative if the area is below the y-axis. If you integrate over an interval that has both, the result will then not represent the complete physical area.

Looking at a graph of your cubic function: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=x^3%2Bx^2-6x

The area under the curve from -2 to 0 is larger than the area "above" the curve from 0 to 2. Since the positive area above (-2,0) is larger than the negative area below (0,2), the total area will be positive.

When I did these calculations, I got an area of 32/3 on (-2,0) and -16/3 on (0,2). So the definite integral on (-2,2) would be 32/3 - 16/3 = 16/3.

The total physical area would be 32/3 + 16/3 = 48/3 = 16. I had to use the absolute value of the areas to calculate the total physical area. I hope this clears things up!
 
Sirsh said:
Hi all, just wondering if someone could explain to me about define integrals.
Say i have F(x)=0.5x2-2 and F(x)=x3+x2-6x and i want to find the area of the regions which is satisfied from -2 to 2.

so [tex]\int[/tex]0.5x2-2 from -2 to 2. [tex]\int[/tex]x3+x2-6x from -2 to 2.

Now with the cubic, from -2 to 0 is supposedly positive and from 0 to 2 it's negative, is that true i thought the it doesn't matter which region the area is in it'll always be counted as positive.

so, [tex]\int[/tex]x3+x2-6x from -2 to 0. = [tex]\int[/tex](-2)3+(-2)2-6(-2) - [tex]\int[/tex](0)3+(0)2-6(0) = 8-0 = 8units2
You haven't integrated anything, you have just evaluated the function itself at -2 and 0 and subtracted. The integral is
[tex]\int_{-2}^0 x^3+ x^2- 6x dx= \left[\frac{1}{4}x^4+ \frac{1}{3}x^3- 3x^2\right]_{-2}^0[/tex]
[tex]= 0- \left(\frac{1}{4}(16)+ \frac{1}{3}(-8)- 3(4)\right)= \frac{32}{3}[/tex]


[tex]\int[/tex]x3+x2-6x from 0 to 2. = [tex]\int[/tex](0)3+(0)2-6(0) - [tex]\int[/tex](2)3+(2)2-6(2) = 0- 0 = 0 units2

Therefore, Area from (-2 to 0)+ Area from (0 to 2) = 8+0 = 8units2

But using my calculator doing the same steps (except in the graphing section) doing -2 to 0 and adding it to 0 to 2's value i get 16units2( 10.667+5.333)

I don't know what's going on..
That's because your calculator integrated and you didn't!
 
With both did you do F(b) - F(a) ? also, do you know anything about these type of intergrals.

[tex]\int[/tex]f(x)dx+|[tex]\int[/tex]f(x)dx|
|[tex]\int[/tex]f(x)dx|+[tex]\int[/tex]f(x)dx
|[tex]\int[/tex]f(x)dx+[tex]\int[/tex]f(x)dx|

I'm unsure what these | | parts do when theyre associated with the integral. thanks a lot.
 
Sirsh said:
With both did you do F(b) - F(a) ? also, do you know anything about these type of intergrals.

[tex]\int[/tex]f(x)dx+|[tex]\int[/tex]f(x)dx|
|[tex]\int[/tex]f(x)dx|+[tex]\int[/tex]f(x)dx
|[tex]\int[/tex]f(x)dx+[tex]\int[/tex]f(x)dx|

I'm unsure what these | | parts do when theyre associated with the integral. thanks a lot.
[tex]\left|\int f(x)dx\right|[/tex]
means "first take the integral of the function then take the absolute value of that number".

[tex]\int |f(x)|dx[/tex]
means "first take the absolute value of the function, then integrate".
 
Wow, I'm so retarded I forgot to actually intergrate the function. how embarrassing..
 
HallsofIvy said:
[tex]\left|\int f(x)dx\right|[/tex]
means "first take the integral of the function then take the absolute value of that number".

[tex]\int |f(x)|dx[/tex]
means "first take the absolute value of the function, then integrate".

Thanks a lot HallsofIvy, I don't really understand. could you please do an example of both?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
5K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
5K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
3K