Solve the given equation that involves fractional exponent

  • Thread starter Thread starter chwala
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    equation
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving the equation 5(x+1)^{1.5}-4x-28=0, where the initial steps lead to a cubic polynomial. The user finds one real root, x=3, but questions arise about the other two roots, which are identified as imaginary. There is concern about the irreversible step of squaring during the solution process and whether the imaginary roots could still be valid solutions. The conversation highlights the importance of considering both real and complex solutions in polynomial equations. The discussion concludes with a reminder of the assumptions made regarding the square root in the original equation.
chwala
Gold Member
Messages
2,825
Reaction score
413
Homework Statement
##5(x+1)^{1.5}-4x-28=0##
Relevant Equations
Algebra.
Is there a better way of solving this,
My steps,
##5(x+1)^{1.5}-4x-28=0##
##(x+1)^{1.5}=\dfrac{4x+28}{5}##
##(x+1)^3=(\dfrac{4x+28}{5})^2##
##x^3+3x^2+3x+1=\dfrac{16(x+7)^2}{25}##
##25x^3+75x^2+75x+25=16(x^2+14x+49)##
##25x^3+59x^2-149x-759=0##

Letting
##f(x)=25x^3+59x^2-149x-759=0##

and using factor theorem,

##f(3)=0##

##⇒x=3##.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
chwala said:
Homework Statement: ##5(x+1)^{1.5}-4x-28=0##
Relevant Equations: Algebra.

Is there a better way of solving this,
My steps,
##5(x+1)^{1.5}-4x-28=0##
##(x+1)^{1.5}=\dfrac{4x+28}{5}##
##(x+1)^3=(\dfrac{4x+28}{5})^2##
##x^3+3x^2+3x+1=\dfrac{16(x+7)^2}{25}##
##25x^3+75x^2+75x+25=16(x^2+14x+49)##
##25x^3+59x^2-149x-759=0##

Letting
##f(x)=25x^3+59x^2-149x-759=0##

and using factor theorem,

##f(3)=0##

##⇒x=3##.
How did you find ##x=3## and what about the two other roots? You also made an irreversible step by squaring. Are the two other roots solutions of the original equation, too?
 
fresh_42 said:
How did you find ##x=3## and what about the two other roots? You also made an irreversible step by squaring. Are the two other roots solutions of the original equation, too?
...by trial and error method around ##x=±0, ±1, ±2, ...##. The other roots are imaginary.

By trial and error, i had already checked using Newton's method and could see where the approximation value was headed to. You may advise on a better way that will incorporate the imaginary solution/s.
 
chwala said:
The other roots are imaginary.
Yes, but they could still provide solutions. I don't think so, but it cannot be ruled out. You haven't said that only real solutions count.
 
I checked the complex solutions
$$
x\in \dfrac{1}{25}\cdot\left\{-67\mp 6\sqrt{51}\;\mathrm{i}\right\}
$$
and it was close:
$$
\dfrac{4}{5}\cdot \dfrac{x+7}{x+1}\in\dfrac{1}{5}\cdot\left\{-3\pm \sqrt{51}\;\mathrm{i}\right\} \quad\text{ and }\quad \sqrt{x+1}\in \dfrac{1}{5}\cdot \left\{3 \mp \sqrt{51} \;\mathrm{i}\right\}
$$
I hope I made no sign error. ##-\sqrt{x+1}=\dfrac{4}{5}\cdot \dfrac{x+7}{x+1}## would have been the other solutions! This means that we made the (silent) assumption that ##(x+1)^{0.5}=+\sqrt{x+1}.##
 
Back
Top