Solve the probability without replacement problem

  • Thread starter chwala
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Probability
2 replies · 1K views · last reply
chwala
Gold Member
Messages
2,854
Reaction score
436
Homework Statement
see attached.
Relevant Equations
understanding of probability concept.
My interest is solely on question ##6.V## only. This is the question paper;

Exam question 6 on a box of 30 biscuits, with a blank 2x3 table to complete and parts (ii) to (v) on probabilities, including part (v) about taking 4 biscuits without replacement and finding the probability of exactly 2 wrapped.


This is my working to solution; I was able to use tree diagram in this question.

Handwritten tree diagram for drawing balls without replacement, branching on W and U at each draw with fractions such as 12/30, 18/30, 11/29, 18/29 and 17/27, followed by numbered probability calculations below.
This is the mark scheme:

Mark scheme for a probability question showing a 2x2 table of wrapped, unwrapped and total counts for choc and not choc, with answers to parts (i) to (v) and the working for P(2 wrapped) without replacement, including 12/30 x 11/29 x 18/28 x 17/27 x 4C2.


I would appreciate other ways of tackling the problem. Cheers! :cool:
 
Attachments
  • Exam question 6 on biscuit probabilities: a box of 30 biscuits, 12 wrapped in gold foil, 17 chocolate-covered, with a blank two-by-two table to complete and parts (i) to (v) asking for probabilities.
    1635772577012.png
    72.3 KB · Views: 197
  • Handwritten tree diagram for a probability without replacement problem, with branches labelled W and U and fractions such as 12/30, 18/30, 11/29, 10/27, followed by numbered calculations and a total of 0.368472.
    1635772653273.png
    51.9 KB · Views: 190
Last edited:
Rather than writing out the tree of all possible outcomes, use combinations.

Imagine the biscuits are numbered 1 to 30, with 1-12 wrapped and the others not.

The answer is N / M where
- N is the number of different possible unordered selections of four with two from 1-12 and two from 13-30
- M is the number of different possible unordered selections of four different biscuits from 1-30

Express M as a combination ##{}_nC_k## and get its value.

Express N as K x L where:
- K is the number of different possible unordered selections of two different biscuits from 1-12
- L is the number of different possible unordered selections of two different biscuits from 13-30

Express K and L as combinations and get their values.

Then you can calculate N, and the n get the answer.

That is the approach set out in your last photo, after the "OR"
 
andrewkirk said:
Rather than writing out the tree of all possible outcomes, use combinations.

Imagine the biscuits are numbered 1 to 30, with 1-12 wrapped and the others not.

The answer is N / M where
- N is the number of different possible unordered selections of four with two from 1-12 and two from 13-30
- M is the number of different possible unordered selections of four different biscuits from 1-30

Express M as a combination ##{}_nC_k## and get its value.

Express N as K x L where:
- K is the number of different possible unordered selections of two different biscuits from 1-12
- L is the number of different possible unordered selections of two different biscuits from 13-30

Express K and L as combinations and get their values.

Then you can calculate N, and the n get the answer.

That is the approach set out in your last photo, after the "OR"
Yes, i am conversant with the combination approach... of course I already looked at it (the marks scheme) before posting this problem, ...i wanted to challenge myself and use a different approach and not just limit myself to the mark scheme. Cheers and thanks Andrewkirk...

the approach of,
##\frac {12C_2 ×18C_2}{30C_4}, ## is more appropriate...