Solving for ##x## for a given inequality

3 replies · 2K views · last reply
brotherbobby
Messages
820
Reaction score
178
Homework Statement
Solve : ##\mathbf{\dfrac{x}{x+2}\le \dfrac{1}{|x|}}##
Relevant Equations
(1) By definition, ##|x| = x## if ##x\ge 0## and ##|x| = -x## if ##x \le 0##.
(2) ##\frac{1}{x}## is not defined for ##x = 0##.
(3) If ##|x| > a\Rightarrow x>a\; \text{or}\; x<-a##
Printed math problem reading: Solve x/(x+2) ≤ 1/|x|
Problem Statement :
I copy and paste the problem from the text to the right.

Attempt (mine) : Given the inequality ##\dfrac{x}{x+2}\le \dfrac{1}{|x|}##. We see immediately that ##x\ne 0, -2##. At the same time, since ##|x|\ge 0\Rightarrow \frac{x}{x+2}\ge 0##.

Now if ##\frac{x}{x+2}\le \frac{1}{|x|}\Rightarrow \frac{1}{|x|}\ge \frac{x}{x+2}##, then we have either ##\frac{1}{x}\ge \frac{x}{x+2}## or ##\frac{1}{x}\le -\frac{x}{x+2}##.

1. The first inequality above reduces to ##\frac{1}{x}-\frac{x}{x+2}\ge 0\Rightarrow \frac{x+2-x^2}{x(x+2)}\ge 0\Rightarrow \frac{x^2-x-2}{x(x+2)}\le 0\Rightarrow \frac{(x-2)(x+1)}{x(x+2)}\le 0## which lead to the answers : ##\boxed{-2<x<-1\; \text{OR}\; 0<x<2}## (note the equality condition is forbidden due to considerations right at the beginning). This can be found by the number line
Sign chart on a number line with tick marks at -2, -1, 0 and 2, showing + in the intervals left of -2, between -1 and 0, and right of 2, and - between -2 and -1 and between 0 and 2, with green arrows marking points between -2 and -1 and between 0 and 2.
pneumonic shown to the right or any other way you are used to with inequalities.

I attach the pictorial pneumonic to the right for those who are used to it. 2. The second inquality above reduces to ##\frac{1}{x}+\frac{x}{x+2}\le 0\Rightarrow \frac{x^2+x+2}{x(x+2}\le 0##. Now we can show using the method of "squaring a quadratic equation" that the numerator ##x^2+x+2>0 \;\;\forall x##. Thus focus falls on the numerator, which yields ##\boxed{-2<x<0}##.

Putting both cases 1 and 2 together and caring for overlaps, my solution for the proble reads : ##\boxed{-2<x<-1\;\;\;\text{OR}\;\;\; 0<x<2}## .

Solution (Text) : I could neither follow, nor agree, with the solution in the text. I copy and paste it below.
Handwritten-style printed solution: x/(x+2) ≤ 1/|x| case split into x ≥ 0 giving 0 ≤ x ≤ 2, and x < 0 giving -2 < x < 0, with the final range -2 < x < 0 underlined in red.


I have underlined what I believe to be the solutions. So ##x=0?!##. Clearly that is not correct. However, the text is right when I take samples from its solutions that are less than zero, for instance ##x = -1, -0.5## etc., solutions which I did not get. Surely my method is mistaken.

A hint or suggestion would be welcome.
 
Your case 1 is when ##x>0## thus the solution ##-2<x<-1## must be disregarded as out of the allowed limit (which is ##x>0##).
 
In addition to @Delta2's point, you have combined your two 'ORed' cases incorrectly. You should have included all of the -2<x<0 results of the second case.
 
brotherbobby said:
I attach the pictorial pneumonic
"Pneumonic" isn't the word you want here. That would be "mnemonic."
 
  • Love
  • Haha
Likes   Reactions: nuuskur and Delta2