Solving Hard Matrix Prob: A+kB Invertible w/ Integer Entries

  • Context: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Thread starter barbiemathgurl
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Hard Matrix
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
4 replies · 4K views
barbiemathgurl
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
i just can't figure this out.

given a n x n matrix (with n>1) "A" such that all entries are integers and A is invertible such that A^{-1} also has integer entries. Let B be another matrix with integer coefficients so that:
A+B, A+2B, A+3B, ... A+(n^2)B
Are all invertible with integer entries.

Show that,
A+kB
Is also invertible with integer enties for any integer k.

who the heck do you solve this?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What can you say about the determinants of those matrices? Once you get this, use the fact that det(A+kB), with A,B known and k a variable, is a polynomial in k.
 
barbiemathgurl said:
i just can't figure this out.

given a n x n matrix (with n>1) "A" such that all entries are integers and A is invertible such that A^{-1} also has integer entries. Let B be another matrix with integer coefficients so that:
A+B, A+2B, A+3B, ... A+(n^2)B
Are all invertible with integer entries.

Show that,
A+kB
Is also invertible with integer enties for any integer k.

who the heck do you solve this?

Let M be an arbitrary square invertible matrix whose inverse and itself has integer entires. Then [tex]1=\det (MM^{-1}) = \det(M)\det (M^{-1})[/tex] shows that [tex]\det (M) = \pm 1[/tex] because the determinant of this matrix must be an integer. Now define the function [tex]f(x) = \det (A+xB)[/tex]. This is a polyomial of at most [tex]n[/tex] degree. Notice that [tex]f(0),f(1),f(2),...,f(n^2)[/tex] are either [tex]1 \mbox{ or }-1[/tex]. By the strong form of the Pigeonhole Principle at least [tex]n+1[/tex] of them are either [tex]1[/tex] or [tex]-1[/tex]. Without lose of generality say its [tex]1[/tex]. That means [tex]f(x)[/tex] must in fact be a constant polynomial because a polynomial of at most [tex]n[/tex] degree cannot produce the same values for [tex]n+1[/tex] different values. So [tex]f(x)=1[/tex]. That means [tex]f(k)=1[/tex] for no matter what [tex]k[/tex]. So [tex]\det (A+kB)=1[/tex]. Since the determinant is 1, it must mean the matrix is irreducible with integer coefficients (by the adjoint matrix formula).
 
Kummer, we try not to give complete solutions here, just hints. And incidentally, a slightly easier way to get the last step is to note that f(k)^2 is a polynomial of degreen n^2 which is 1 at n^2+1 points, so must be 1 identically, and so f(k)=+-1. Also it remains to show that all integer matrices with determinant +-1 are invertible with integer entries.
 
StatusX said:
Kummer, we try not to give complete solutions here, just hints.
Okay.

Also it remains to show that all integer matrices with determinant +-1 are invertible with integer entries.
Last line in my first post in paranthesis. I was being sloppy on that last line because I assumed that result was trivial. I should have been more explicit.