I Speed of EM & Mech Waves: Maxwell's Law Explained

Click For Summary
Maxwell's Law defines the speed of light as c = 1/√(ε₀μ₀), indicating that electromagnetic waves travel at this speed in a vacuum. The discussion centers on whether a medium can allow mechanical waves to travel faster than electromagnetic waves. It is noted that mechanical waves propagate through electromagnetic interactions, typically at speeds much lower than that of light. The idea of using materials with high refractive indices to slow light is considered, but it is argued that mechanical waves cannot exceed the speed of electromagnetic waves in such cases. Additionally, while electrons can exceed light speed in a medium, they quickly decelerate and emit Cerenkov radiation.
Barblorrane
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
TL;DR
Can mechanical waves be faster than electromagnetic waves?
Based on Maxwell's Law, the speed of light can be defined by:

$$c= \frac{1}{\sqrt{\epsilon_{0}\mu_{0}}}$$

Based on that, can we find a medium where a mechanical wave travels faster than a electromagnetic one? If so, how does that works?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
You've written an expression for the speed of light in vacuum. Materials are held together by electromagnetic forces, so changes in the material, such as mechanical waves, propagate via the electromagnetic interaction, so at or below (usually many orders of magnitude below) that speed.

Did you mean a material with a very high refractive index so that light travels very slowly in it? I don't think you can have mechanical waves traveling faster than electromagnetic waves in such a circumstance, for much the same reason as above.

Other things such as electrons may exceed the speed of light in the medium, although they rapidly slow down, emitting Cerenkov radiation as they do.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Cosmic Lollipop, Barblorrane and vanhees71
The Poynting vector is a definition, that is supposed to represent the energy flow at each point. Unfortunately, the only observable effect caused by the Poynting vector is through the energy variation in a volume subject to an energy flux through its surface, that is, the Poynting theorem. As a curl could be added to the Poynting vector without changing the Poynting theorem, it can not be decided by EM only that this should be the actual flow of energy at each point. Feynman, commenting...