Supernova step of core collapse

  • Context: High School 
  • Thread starter Thread starter GIASAL
  • Start date Start date
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
8 replies · 169 views
GIASAL
Messages
4
Reaction score
1
The steps involved in the collapse of a supernova's core are often incomplete and often contradictory.
Could you point me to a resource where these steps are clearly indicated?
Thanks
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
GIASAL said:
The steps involved in the collapse of a supernova's core are often incomplete and often contradictory.
Can you please cite specific textbooks or references that you think are incomplete or contradictory about supernova collapse?
 
GIASAL said:
I aimed to accurately list the various stages of the implosion.
Sorry, did I miss this? Where do you list the various stages of the implosion?
GIASAL said:
However, there are differences in the order of succession, or some steps are ignored.
But what specifically are the differences or ignored steps that concern you?
GIASAL said:
For example, Wiki has a different description of the collapse, such as this site:
https://astronomy.swin.edu.au/cosmos/c/core-collapse
Good, you've cited one description of stellar collapse. Now can you reference another description that you judge to be different and list those differences so we can compare and comment?
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Motore and Matterwave
Thanks for your reply.
To better understand the differences, are you aware of any particularly comprehensive resources on stellar collapse? That way I can better explain the differences.
I need to write the differences I found carefully to be accurate.
Can I send you the text of my research so you can give me some advice?
 
Supernovae are quite complex phenomena and are generally only lightly covered at the undergraduate level. You may start to see more comprehensive reviews at the graduate level, in a book like Shapiro and Teukolsky "Black Holes, White Dwarfs, and Neutron Stars" -- the ending chapter 18 has a treatment of core collapse supernovae.

However, the detailed mechanisms are still being researched so if you want something truly comprehensive you might have to review the research literature in academic journals.
 
Is it possible to write a description of the main phases in a form suitable for secondary schools ?
 
GIASAL said:
To better understand the differences, are you aware of any particularly comprehensive resources on stellar collapse?
Yes, but such a comprehensive resource is typically well above High-School level. One good example is:
The evolution and explosion of massive stars, §V.
 
Reply
  • Love
Likes   Reactions: Matterwave
GIASAL said:
Is it possible to write a description of the main phases in a form suitable for secondary schools ?
Yes, but such a treatment necessarily glosses over a lot of details. Details that you might be referring to when you say the treatments you read are "incomplete or contradictory". This is why @renormalize keeps asking you to provide what statements you find contradictory. What treatments you find incomplete.