Surface area using double integrals

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around finding the surface area of a triangle defined by its vertices (0,0), (L,L), and (L,-L) using double integrals. Participants explore the concept of surface area in relation to calculus and double integrals, questioning the necessity of integrals for calculating area compared to traditional formulas.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the form of the double integral needed to calculate the area, with some expressing confusion about the integrand and the limits of integration. Questions arise regarding the definition of dA and its relation to different coordinate systems. Others suggest using the integrand as 1 for area calculations.

Discussion Status

The conversation is active, with various interpretations of how to set up the double integral being explored. Some participants provide insights into the limits of integration and the form of the integrand, while others express uncertainty about the correct setup. There is no explicit consensus, but several productive directions have been suggested.

Contextual Notes

Participants note constraints such as the inability to use the traditional area formula A = bh/2 and the need for clarity on the definition of dA. There is also mention of the need for graphical representation to aid in understanding the limits of integration.

Carnivroar
Messages
128
Reaction score
1
Find the surface area of the triangle with vertices (0,0) (L, L) (L,-L)

I know I have to take the double integrals of f(x,y) but I have no idea what f(x,y) is supposed to be!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Why do you need an integral to find the area of a triangle?
Why not good old A = bh/2 ?
 
A surface area in the form of a double integral will be in the form:

∫∫dA
 
But Delphi's answer is just as good too if you simply would like to know a double integral and not use any calculus. :]
 
Oops, I mean area, not double integral.
 
thepatient said:
A surface area in the form of a double integral will be in the form:

∫∫dA

what's dA? I wasn't there during the lecture so I'm lost. I looked through my textbooks, online, and I can't find anything. All I think I know is that I need a f(x, y).

And no I can't use bh/2. But it's good because I know my answer from the double integral has to be something like bh/2 so I can verify my answer.
 
dA would be dxdy. You will first have to integrate with respect to x or y, then integrate with respect to the second variable. If your double integrals limits of integration are just numbers, will give you the area of a rectangle. Your limits of integration can also be functions as well though.
 
thepatient said:
dA would be dxdy. You will first have to integrate with respect to x or y, then integrate with respect to the second variable. If your double integrals limits of integration are just numbers, will give you the area of a rectangle. Your limits of integration can also be functions as well though.

but what do i integrate?

∫∫(?)dydx
 
dA is basically a very small element of the area and depends on the type of coordinate system you use as well. If you just take a very small rectangle to be dA, then your dA will be dx dy. If you're using polar coordinates and your dA is a strip defined by the radius and the angle, then dA = r dr d(theta).

When you integrate, you hold every other variable that you're not integrating over as a constant. For example, let's say you have the double integral of y+x dydx.

∫x = 0..2 ∫y = 0..3 y+x dy dx

Integrating with respect to y, holding all other variables constant:

∫x=0..2 y^2/2 + xy | y = 0..3 dx =

∫x = 0..2 4.5 + 3x dx =

4.5x + 3x^2/2 x = 0..2 =

9 + 6 = 15.
 
  • #10
thepatient said:
dA is basically a very small element of the area and depends on the type of coordinate system you use as well. If you just take a very small rectangle to be dA, then your dA will be dx dy. If you're using polar coordinates and your dA is a strip defined by the radius and the angle, then dA = r dr d(theta).

When you integrate, you hold every other variable that you're not integrating over as a constant. For example, let's say you have the double integral of y+x dydx.

∫x = 0..2 ∫y = 0..3 y+x dy dx

Integrating with respect to y, holding all other variables constant:

∫x=0..2 y^2/2 + xy | y = 0..3 dx =

∫x = 0..2 4.5 + 3x dx =

4.5x + 3x^2/2 x = 0..2 =

9 + 6 = 15.

I know how to do double integrals but I don't know what should come here ∫∫(??)dydx

The image is a triangle

It looks like this

hefjewfwef.png
 
  • #11
In your case, you will have:

x=bx=ay = g(x)y = h(x)dydx

Or you can have it in the form of:
y=dy=cx= g(y)x = h(y)dxdy

But in your case I think it would be easier to do the first. The integrand will just be 1 dydx.

So you will have to find an upper limit function and a lower limit function. Once you have those functions and you integrate, then you integrate with respect to your other variable and use your limits a to b.

You may want to graph the triangle. Your upper limit will be the equation of a line of form y = mx + b and your lower limit will be when y = 0. I'm not sure if I'm allowed to just give out the answer. XD Give it a try and look up some example problems on the book too. :]
 
  • #12
Ooh in that case, you will have your limits as y = mx +b and y = -wx + h, where m and w are separate slopes of each line and b and h are different y intercepts. You will still be integrating simply over 1 dydx.
 
  • #13
In summary, a double integral of 1 gives you an area, a triple integral of 1 gives you a volume.
 
  • #14
positive slope = 1x + 0 = x
negative slope = -1x + 0 = -x

not sure if I'm sticking them in the right place

Code:
 x   x
 ∫   ∫ dydx
-x   0

I got x2

I guess that's the same thing as L2

I plugged in some numbers on the bh/2 formula and they seem to agree

wow so simple.

am I correct now?
 
  • #15
Actually I think it should be the other way around

Code:
 x   x 
∫   ∫ dydx
0   -x

Still comes out to x2
 
  • #16
Very good. :] Now imagine if you were to cut the triangle right in half through the x axis, and fit the bottom half on the top left of the top half. You have a rectangle with area of L^2.
 
  • #17
thepatient said:
Very good. :] Now imagine if you were to cut the triangle right in half through the x axis, and fit the bottom half on the top left of the top half. You have a rectangle with area of L^2.

Yep, thanks!
 
  • #18
Mathematically, you would probably want to change your x limits from 0 to x to limits of 0 to x prime, or another letter.
 

Similar threads

Replies
39
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
972
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
1K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
995
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
2K