Tabular Method for a Unique Spur Gear Differential System

2 replies · 3K views · last reply
Nick Amos
Messages
2
Reaction score
1
Hello everyone, this is my first post here so please excuse me if its in the wrong area.

I am looking for the tabular approach to solve a complex gear train based off the spur gear differential design. Attached is a photo of the differential.
Cutaway drawing of a spur gear differential in a cylindrical housing, showing two sun gears and a set of planet gears meshing between them, with shafts extending from both ends.


The requirements of the necessary differential will be:

Sun-Gear 1 as input,

Carrier or Sun-Gear 2/Annular gear as outputs. Only one output will be in motion at any given time.

The velocity of the outputs must be equal.

A condition of the differential in the above photo is that the carrier velocity ratio is an average of the velocity of the two sun gears. When applied to the above conditions, the outputs would not be equal. The annular gear output would be equal and opposite to the input, while the carrier output would be equal to 1/2 the input speed.

To achieve the equal output velocities, the ratios of either sun to planet set can be modified, as well as the ratio of planet to planet. I am a novice with tabular gear train solutions and am confused by which method to move forward with in order to solve this.

The first possible solution I thought would be in a modification to the tabular method used for Reverted epicyclic gear trains.
Diagram of a spur gear differential with two sun gears of different sizes, labeled B, C, D and E, a central planet gear labeled A, and a connecting carrier bar; dashed and solid circles show pitch and gear outlines.


The second, was a modified version of the method used for compound epicyclic gear trains.
Diagram of a spur gear differential: left, a sectional view with compound gear D, internal gear G, arm, shafts A and B, and gear C; right, a front view showing gears C, D, E and G.


In order to modify the reverted design, the gears D and E would no longer be compound and the ratio of the two would be necessary in calculations. In the compound epicyclic case, the Annular gear would have external teeth and its rotational direction changed as well as Gears D and E not being compound.

Here is a simple photo showing the method permitting modified ratios. Sun Gear A would be the input. The outputs would be either Carrier H or Annular GearD/Sun Gear 2.
Schematic of a spur gear differential: large annular gear D surrounds sun gear A, with a carrier arm H and planet gears B and C meshing between them.


If the Annular gear is the Output, Gears B and C act as Idlers and the ratio of input to output is that of A:D, properly expressed: NA/NB X NB/NC X NC/ND or simply NA/ND

This is where I need help. When tabulated, what does this method look like? I've come up with what I thought was the right table, but when comparing the equations for gears b and c to those of similar complex systems It seems I'm missing some things. Once I have the table I should be able to use the formulas and set the ratios between gears by using my operational parameter that the velocity of H must be equal to that of NA/ND right?

Here is what I believe is the right table representing this method of motion.
Table titled Revolutions of Elements listing motion conditions for arm H, sun A, wheel B, wheel C and annulus D, with rows for fixed-arm input, fixed-arm wheel A turned x, adding Y revolutions, and total motion.


Any help or direction is greatly appreciated!
 
Attachments
  • Cutaway drawing of a spur gear differential in a cylindrical housing, showing two sun gears and a set of planet gears meshing between them, with shafts extending from both ends.
    SGD.jpg
    61.7 KB · Views: 925
  • Diagram of a spur gear differential with two sun gears of different sizes, labeled B, C, D and E, a central planet gear labeled A, and a connecting carrier bar; dashed and solid circles show pitch and gear outlines.
    reverted epicyclic gear train.jpg
    7.9 KB · Views: 838
  • Diagram of a spur gear differential: left, a sectional view with compound gear D, internal gear G, arm, shafts A and B, and gear C; right, a front view showing gears C, D, E and G.
    compound epicyclic gear train.jpg
    8.2 KB · Views: 868
  • Schematic of a spur gear differential: large annular gear D surrounds sun gear A, with a carrier arm H and planet gears B and C meshing between them.
    Screenshot (322).png
    4.3 KB · Views: 779
  • Table titled Revolutions of Elements listing motion conditions for arm H, sun A, wheel B, wheel C and annulus D, with rows for fixed-arm input, fixed-arm wheel A turned x, adding Y revolutions, and total motion.
    Screenshot (323).png
    10.2 KB · Views: 789
Not homework, but a personal project. I'm a machinist by trade and designing and building a clock from scratch.

The Diff. I'm looking to build is to solve for Opposite Co-axial rotation to power an escapement.
These are some screengrabs of the clock and the two stacks needing power from the Diff.
SolidWorks assembly screenshot of a clock gear train with a spur gear differential: stacked brass and copper-coloured gears on a shaft, a blue carrier piece, and a ratchet wheel and pawl assembly, beside a feature tree on the left.
Screenshot of a SolidWorks assembly of a mechanical clock movement on a wooden base, showing a gear train, escapement, and balance wheel with bridges and posts, and an assembly feature tree on the left.
 
Attachments
  • SolidWorks assembly screenshot of a clock gear train with a spur gear differential: stacked brass and copper-coloured gears on a shaft, a blue carrier piece, and a ratchet wheel and pawl assembly, beside a feature tree on the left.
    Screenshot (270).png
    53.4 KB · Views: 778
  • Screenshot of a SolidWorks assembly of a mechanical clock movement on a wooden base, showing a gear train, escapement, and balance wheel with bridges and posts, and an assembly feature tree on the left.
    Screenshot (279).png
    56 KB · Views: 698