The laws of thermodynamics and the Universe

In summary: DrakkithOK, thank you for your reply.The first and second laws of thermodynamics still apply to the universe, though they may not be as strictly followed as they are in closed systems. The first law of thermodynamics states that energy is not always conserved, while the second law of thermodynamics states that entropy will always increase in a closed system.
  • #1
PhysicsNoob00
7
1
TL;DR Summary
the laws of thermodynamics as applied to the universe's creation and existence
How would the first and second laws of thermodynamics apply to the creation and existence of the universe? I'm not a physicist (and unfortunately, do not remember a lot that I learned in Physics class in school and college about Thermodynamics). I did some searching and I have come across an article on Wikipedia that the first law of thermodynamics doesn't apply to the universe. I'm stumped as to why this is the case. Is it because its an isolated system (the argument being that the universe as a whole, not just the observable universe, has no surroundings)? However, the second law of thermodynamics is applicable only to closed systems (entropy, measure of disorder in a closed system). How would the other laws apply? If someone could give me an answer bearing in mind that I'm a layman, it would be great. Here's the wiki link:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermodynamics_of_the_universe

Thanks.
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
PhysicsNoob00 said:
How would the first and second laws of thermodynamics apply to the creation and existence of the universe?

No one knows. We don't even know how the universe came into existence, or if it has always existed in some form.

PhysicsNoob00 said:
I did some searching and I have come across an article on Wikipedia that the first law of thermodynamics doesn't apply to the universe. I'm stumped as to why this is the case.

That's a problematic question to answer. The issue is that energy is not necessarily conserved in cosmology because it isn't necessarily conserved in general relativity. See this article: http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Relativity/GR/energy_gr.html

I can't say much about your other questions unfortunately. Perhaps someone else here can help you.
 
  • Like
Likes PhysicsNoob00
  • #3
@Drakkith OK, thank you for your reply
 
  • #4
Thermodynamics becomes really weird when gravitation is involved.

For example, a planet in thermal equilibrium with the universe will be warmer at the center, because of the gravitational energy shift of photons.
Then there are black holes, which have a negative heat capacity. That does not sound particularly interesting, but it means that a system that seems to be in a thermal equilibrium with constant temperature can spontaneously transition to a state that contains a black hole, and that is very much not in a thermal equilibrium.
 
  • Like
Likes krater
  • #5
@Gigaz Thank you for your reply. I did find some interesting opinions about black holes with respect to their temperature, but I suppose that discussion would belong in an entirely new thread.
 
  • #6
While it is unclear if the conservation law applies as mentioned by others above. The universe is typically modeled as an adiabatic system. Adiabatic meaning no net inflow or outflow of energy.
 
  • #7
If the universe has no surroundings then it is a closed system. It has no environment in which anything can exit into or enter from. Therefore, in that case the first law applies.
 
  • #8
@Mordred Thank you for your reply

@Erk I think you are talking about the universe as an isolated system, where no energy and mass is exchanged with the surroundings.
 
  • #9
Yes. You mentioned the notion of a universe with no surroundings, and that was what I was responding to. The absolute absence of an environment, including (and not except for) absolutely nothing. This speaks to the first law and also a perpetual universe. Without absolutely nothing there isn't anything for the universe to come from. Assuming absolutely nothing as ever existing has always been a mistake. After all, if absolutely nothing existed there wouldn't be absolutely nothing.
 
  • #10
@Erk and @Mordred Aren't all isolated systems also adiabatic systems? Then that would imply that the modeling of the universe would be incorrect (since something cannot exist from absolutely nothing). However, the universe is usually modeled as an adiabatic system. What am I missing here, w.r.t. to your replies to my question? Sorry if I sound stupid.
 
  • #11
Since an adiabatic system is within a surrounding the notion that it's the same as a closed system is highly suspicious. It has never been determined there is a scale at which an impenetrable surface actually exists.
 
  • #12
@Erk OK, thank you for your reply
 
  • #13
Another way to think of it is that with regards to the universe. The terms homogeneous and isotropy are important in terms of the cosmological principle. We can only determine the thermodynamic state of our observable universe. Which according to the datasets appear strongly homogeneous and isotropic.
From this we can surmise some educated guesses that the region's immediately outside our observable portion must also be of a similar thermodynamic state. As a significant differences would induce some form of flow which would not be isotropic. An easy example is pressure differentials induce flow. We see no signs of a flow so region's immediately (within causal range) must be in the same state. This then means that no net flow of energy either enters or leaves our observable portion due to thermodynamic differentials.

One must ignore the container walls applications when applying the gas laws as there is no such barrier with regards to our universe. Instead one must switch to applying causality region's. Obviously nothing flows faster than c, however each medium has its own flow rate depending on such factors such as density.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes PhysicsNoob00
  • #14
In essence we can treat our observable universe as an adiabatic system while not necessarily a closed system
 
  • #15
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermodynamics_of_the_universe

You can how the gas laws applies to the adiabatic expansion on the above link on terms of formula usage
From the formulas in the first link one can better understand how the equations of state cosmology were derived
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equation_of_state_(cosmology)
 
Last edited:
  • #16
Your question can be answered in the same way that Thomas Aquinas' "first cause" proof of God is invalidated. His argument is that, since we always observe that any given event has a cause before it, it's necessarily true that there must be a First Cause that started the whole chain of events. The fallacy is that, even though we experience that every event has a preceding cause, we have no experience observing entire chains of events with first causes. Thus, to your question, we observe that the First and Second laws are valid for "normal kinds" of observable systems (excluding black holes and other issues in GR), but we have no experience observing the behavior of entire Universes. The above comment that these laws are messed up by black holes and GR is instructive, indicating that if such observable systems can be so baffling, certainly entire Universes can be at least incomprehensible.
 
  • Like
Likes PhysicsNoob00
  • #17
  • Like
Likes Drakkith

FAQ: The laws of thermodynamics and the Universe

1. What are the laws of thermodynamics?

The laws of thermodynamics are fundamental principles that govern the behavior of energy in a system. They describe how energy is transferred and transformed within a system, and how this affects the overall state of the system.

2. How many laws of thermodynamics are there?

There are four laws of thermodynamics, each building upon the previous one. The first law states that energy cannot be created or destroyed, only transferred or transformed. The second law states that the total entropy of a closed system will always increase over time. The third law states that the entropy of a perfect crystal at absolute zero temperature is zero. The fourth law, also known as the zeroth law, states that if two systems are in thermal equilibrium with a third system, they are also in thermal equilibrium with each other.

3. How do the laws of thermodynamics relate to the Universe?

The laws of thermodynamics are universal and apply to all systems, including the Universe. They help explain the behavior of energy within the Universe, such as the expansion of the Universe and the formation of stars and galaxies. The second law of thermodynamics also plays a role in the eventual heat death of the Universe.

4. Can the laws of thermodynamics be violated?

No, the laws of thermodynamics are considered to be universal and absolute. They have been extensively tested and have never been found to be violated. However, there are some cases where it may seem like the laws are being violated, but upon closer examination, they are actually being followed.

5. How do the laws of thermodynamics impact our daily lives?

The laws of thermodynamics have many practical applications in our daily lives. They help us understand and improve processes such as energy production, refrigeration, and combustion. They also play a role in fields such as chemistry, biology, and engineering. Understanding the laws of thermodynamics can also help us make more sustainable and efficient use of energy resources.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
3K
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
2K
Back
Top