1. Not finding help here? Sign up for a free 30min tutor trial with Chegg Tutors
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

The points at which a f is continuous is a G-delta

  1. Nov 30, 2007 #1
    Now that I have finished with the 7 chapters of rudin i plan to study Part 1 of royden's real analysis. Here is a problem regarding borel sets

    Let f be a real valued function defined for all reals. Prove that the set of points at which f is continuous can be written as a countable intersection of open sets.

    set y=f(x)

    Consider the family of open sets, N_{1/n} (y) for every real y, call it V_n (y). Taking preimages of these sets will yield some open sets and some not. Let O_n be the union of the collection of preimages that are open, then O_n is open. Put
    O=intersection of O_n.

    If f is continuous at x the preimage of every V_n(f(x)) is open so it is contained in O_n which means that x is in O. Now if x is in O then x is in O_n for every n. Let e>0, pick a N so that 1/N<e/2. Then x is inside the preimage of some V_N (z). Since this the preimage of this V_N (z) is open, call it N(z), there exists a delta>0 so that if d(x,y)<delta then y is in N(z). Also
    |f(x)-f(y)| <\= |f(x)-f(z)|+|f(y)-f(z)|<e

    we have shown O is the set of points where f is continuous.

    Can someone tell me if I'm missing something, i just feel like i am.

  2. jcsd
  3. Nov 30, 2007 #2
    I had to stop reading at this point because f continuous at x does not imply [tex]f^{-1}(N_e(f(x)))[/tex] is open. For instance, take f(x) = 0 for |x| <= 1, and f(x) = 2 for x > 1. You get [tex]f^{-1}((-1,1)) = [-1,1][/tex]. You are ensured the preimages are open only when f is continuous everywhere.
  4. Nov 30, 2007 #3
    Sorry the assertion was completely false but it can be reformulated so it becomes a local property. If f is continuous at x for every epsilon neighborhood around f(x) (called V_n (x)) there exists a delta neighborhood (called D_n (x)) so that f(D_n(x)) is contained in V_n(x).

    Consider the family of V_n(x) for all x in R, when such a D_n (x) exists put it in O_n. So O_n is the union of a family of open sets and is therefore open.
    Let O_n be the union of D_n's when they exist as such.

    Again O=intersection of O_n

    If f is continuous at x then there will always be a neighborhood D_n (x) so that f(D_n(x)) is contained in V_n (x) so that x is in O. Now let e>0 and x in O, there exists a N so that 1/N<e/2. Then x is in some D_n(z) which is a neighborhood of z and is open, so there exists a neighborhood of x contained inside D_n(z). Now for every y in D_n(z) we know that
    |f(z)-f(y)|<e/2 so that
    as long as y is in the neighborhood of x which is contained inside D_n(z).
  5. Dec 1, 2007 #4
    When f is continuous at x, you associate an open [tex]D_n(x) \subset B(x,1/n)[/tex] so that [tex]f(D_n(x)) \subset B(f(x),1/n)[/tex]. Then [tex]O_n[/tex] is the union of all [tex]D_n(x)[/tex], such that f is continuous at x. Clearly, [tex]O = \cap O_n[/tex] contains all the continuity points (because each continuity point by definition is in a [tex]D_n \subset O_n[/tex]), and also O is a countable intersection of open sets.

    You still need to show O does not contain a discontinuity point. If a discontinuity point p is in O. Then p is in some [tex]D_n(p_n) \subset B(p_n,1/n)[/tex] for all n (where [tex]f(D_n(p_n)) \subset B(f(p_n),1/n)[/tex]). Then fix e > 0 such that for every d > 0, there is a q such that d(p,q) < d and d(f(p),f(q)) > e. Then for 1/N < e/2, you have p in D_N(p_N), and thus some q in D_N(p_N) such that d(f(p),f(q)) > e, but also [tex]d(f(p),f(q)) \leq d(p,p_N) + d(p_N,q) < e/2 + e/2[/tex], a contradiction.
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Have something to add?

Similar Discussions: The points at which a f is continuous is a G-delta
  1. G-delta set theorem (Replies: 11)