Thermal Physics Problem -- Dropping a hot mass of iron into 20C water

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
4 replies · 2K views
Woopa
Messages
20
Reaction score
4
Homework Statement
A piece of iron of mass 200g and temperature 300 degrees celcius is dropped into 1.00kg of water of temperature 20 degrees celcius.

Predict the final equilibrium of the water.

(Take c for iron as 540 J/kg/K and for water as 4200 J/kg/K).
Relevant Equations
Q=mcΔT)
Hi,

The solution for this question is

thermal energy lost= thermal energy gained
0.200x450x(300-T)=1.0x4200x(T-20)
T=26 degrees celsius.

However, I am struggling to grasp why (300-T) is used.

I have always known a change in something to be final - initial. Therefore change in T= Final- initial.

However, in the case of (300-T) Initial- Final is being used for the change and I am struggling to understand why.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The solution is poorly presented and that is why you are struggling to understand it. The starting equation is
##m_1 c_1 \Delta T_1 + m_2 c_2\Delta T_2=0##.
If you replace the Deltas with actual differences, you get
##m_1 c_1 (T-T_1) + m_2 c_2(T-T_2)=0##.
Now move one of the terms to the other side of the equation and change sign
##m_1 c_1 (T-T_1) = - m_2 c_2(T-T_2) =+ m_2 c_2(T_2-T).##
 
kuruman said:
The solution is poorly presented and that is why you are struggling to understand it. The starting equation is
##m_1 c_1 \Delta T_1 + m_2 c_2\Delta T_2=0##.
If you replace the Deltas with actual differences, you get
##m_1 c_1 (T-T_1) + m_2 c_2(T-T_2)=0##.
Now move one of the terms to the other side of the equation and change sign
##m_1 c_1 (T-T_1) = - m_2 c_2(T-T_2) =+ m_2 c_2(T_2-T).##
Excellent I've got it! Thank you!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: kuruman and Lnewqban
Woopa said:
Excellent I've got it! Thank you!
You are welcome. BTW if you use the heat capacity ##C## instead of the product of mass and specific heat heat, the answer takes a familiar form $$T=\frac{C_1T_1+C_2T_2}{C_1+C_2}$$ which is just like the expression for the center of mass of two masses. The final equilibrium temperature is the heat-capacity-averaged temperature much like the center of mass is the mass-averaged position. With this in mind, you can have ##N## objects at different initial temperatures thrown together in a calorimeter and be able to write down the final temperature immediately:$$T_{\text{final}}=\frac{m_1c_1T_1+m_2c_2T_2+\dots+m_Nc_NT_N}{m_1c_1+m_2c_2+\dots+m_Nc_N}.$$