- #1
En_lizard
- 76
- 0
suppose someone claims that he's a mechanical engineer who you make sure that he really is, or rather he's a good one?
Things that a mechanical engineer must know for sure
- Thread starter En_lizard
- Start date
Click For Summary
Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the qualifications and competencies of mechanical engineers, exploring how to verify someone's credentials and assess their expertise. It touches on the broader implications of engineering qualifications across various disciplines.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Conceptual clarification
- Meta-discussion
Main Points Raised
- Some participants suggest that verifying a mechanical engineer's credentials can be done by checking their resume and educational background.
- Others argue that having a degree alone does not guarantee someone is a good engineer; an engineering mindset is also essential.
- There is a humorous exchange about asking for resumes and references, indicating a light-hearted approach to the topic.
- One participant mentions that engaging in conversation can help identify the quality of an engineer's expertise.
- Another participant expresses a desire for more meaningful discussions with engineers, seeking specific topics to explore.
- There are references to the presence of knowledgeable engineers within the forum, suggesting a community of expertise.
- A participant humorously mentions the idea of obtaining a degree in "social engineering," indicating a playful tone in the discussion.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally agree that verifying credentials is important, but there is disagreement on the sufficiency of a degree to determine someone's capability as an engineer. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the best methods to assess engineering expertise.
Contextual Notes
Some statements reflect personal opinions and experiences rather than established criteria for evaluating engineers. The discussion includes humor and informal exchanges, which may affect the seriousness of the topic.
- #2
russ_watters
Mentor
- 23,829
- 11,305
Ask to see a resume with references.
- #3
FredGarvin
Science Advisor
- 5,093
- 10
Whether a person is a degreed engineer is relatively easy to find out. Like Russ said, get a resume that states where they graduated from and check. The question of whether they are a good engineer or not is tough and may not be answerable with interview questioning.
- #4
En_lizard
- 76
- 0
can i see your resumes then? with references pleaze!
- #5
Mech_Engineer
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 2,587
- 172
En_lizard said:
How's this for an answer: NO
Ask a specific question and you'll get many informed and knowledgeable answers. There are many industry professionals on this site that make sure no one is giving bad info.
- #6
En_lizard
- 76
- 0
Mech_Engineer said:How's this for an answer: NO
Ask a specific question and you'll get many informed and knowledgeable answers. There are many industry professionals on this site that make sure no one is giving bad info.
i just wanted to have some nice discussions with one of the friends whos a mech eng! so i need some topic to ask from him
- #7
Cornellian
- 13
- 0
En_lizard said:
HAHA... This is Hilarious!
- #8
ank_gl
- 741
- 0
i don't think that just having a major degree in mechanical engineering means that you are one. and not only mechanical engineering, i m talking of all sorts of engineering, be it civil, electrical or electronics. its an engineering mind that makes an engineer.
and about spotting the difference, you just need to talk to them. anyone can tell here that Mr. Fredgarvin is a far more better engineer than most of us
and about spotting the difference, you just need to talk to them. anyone can tell here that Mr. Fredgarvin is a far more better engineer than most of us
- #9
FredGarvin
Science Advisor
- 5,093
- 10
If you're trying to butter me up...it's working.
There are a bunch of very good engineers on this board.
There are a bunch of very good engineers on this board.
- #10
daveb
- 547
- 2
FredGarvin said:
Oh yeah! Name 316!
- #11
NateTG
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
- 2,449
- 7
FredGarvin said:
Apparently, ank_gl is working on his social engineering. A field that the OP might study a bit more.
- #12
ank_gl
- 741
- 0
nah not any social engineering. and sorry for including names. its just that he helped me once, that's why i said so. sorry if you don't like it
- #13
FredGarvin
Science Advisor
- 5,093
- 10
Ank...we're just joking around. No worries.
- #14
Langbein
- 209
- 0
I think I should need to have such a degree in social engineering as well.
I have heard that this degree MSE - can be something rather expeceve to obtain.
Does anybody know a web based university or something where the Master of Social Engineering can be obtained for some slightly less amount of money ?
I have heard that this degree MSE - can be something rather expeceve to obtain.
Does anybody know a web based university or something where the Master of Social Engineering can be obtained for some slightly less amount of money ?