Third QG-Americas conference 24-26 August

  • Context: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Thread starter marcus
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Conference
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the upcoming Third QG-Americas conference scheduled for August 24-26 at Penn State. Participants share details about the conference program, express interest in reports from attendees, and discuss the implications of notable absences, such as Lee Smolin. The conversation also touches on the content of presentations and the accuracy of reported information.

Discussion Character

  • Meta-discussion
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • Details of the conference program were shared, including session topics and speakers.
  • Some participants expressed a desire for reports from attendees, particularly Yidun Wan, who is expected to provide insights from the conference.
  • Concerns were raised about the absence of Lee Smolin, which some believe may affect the conference's dynamics.
  • Yidun Wan mentioned writing a "not a report" that some found unsatisfactory, indicating a need for more comprehensive coverage of the conference.
  • There was a discussion about the accuracy of a statement regarding Laurent Freidel's talk, with a participant suggesting a potential error in the description of his framework for spin foam quantum gravity.
  • Clarifications were made regarding the intended recovery of quantum field theory and classical gravity in specific limits, with acknowledgment of previous mistakes in the report.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the importance of accurate reporting from the conference, but there are differing views on the implications of Lee Smolin's absence and the accuracy of the information presented in Yidun Wan's blog.

Contextual Notes

There are unresolved questions regarding the timing of audio and PDF releases of the conference talks, as well as the accuracy of specific technical claims made in the reports.

marcus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
Dearly Missed
Messages
24,752
Reaction score
795
thanks to Yidun Wan for this reminder
http://www.wanyidun.com/blog_r2u/
the third QG-Americas conference will be held at Penn State

Conference Program

Thursday, August 24th:

1. 9:00-10:30 AM: Renormalization Group and Einstein Gravity. Chair: Max Niedermaier (max at phys.univ-tours.fr); Rapporteur: Frank Saueressig (40 minutes); Robert Oeckl (15)

2. 11:00-12:30PM: Loop Quantum Cosmology . Chair: David Craig (craigda at lemoyne.edu); Rapporteur: Parampreet Singh (40); Tomasz Pawlowski (15)

3. 2:00-3:30PM: Cosmology and Observations. Chair: Ted Jacobson (tajac at physics.umd.edu); Rapporteurs: Daniel Sudarsky and Nelson Nunes (25+10 each)

4. 4:00-5:30PM: Effective Descriptions. Chair: Martin Bojowald (bojowald at gravity.psu.edu); Rapporteurs: Laurent Friedel and Radu Roiban (25+10 each).

Friday, August 25th:

5. 9:00-10:30AM: Discrete Approaches. Chair: Rodolfo Gambini (rgambini at fisica.edu.uy); Rapporteurs: Luca Bombelli and Jorge Pullin. (25+10 each)

6. 11:00-12:30PM: The Physical Sector of LQG. Chair: Jorge Pullin (pullin at lsu.edu); Rapporteurs: Jerzy Lewandowski and Bianca Dittrich (25+10 each)

7. 2:00-3:30PM: Spin Foams. Chair: Laurent Freidel (lfreidel at perimeterinstitute.ca); Rapporteurs: Robert Oeckl and Florian Conrady (25+10 each)

8. 4:00PM-5:30PM: Quantum Geometry and Matter. Chair: Seth Major (smajor at hamilton.edu); Rapporteurs: Kevin Vandersloot, Mikhail Kagan (20+5 each) and Fotini Markopoulou (25+5)

Saturday, August 26th:

9. 9:00-10:30AM: Quantum Gravity Phenomenology. Chair: Daniel Sudarsky (sudarsky at nucleares.unam.mx); Rapporteur: David Mattingly (40)

10. 11:00-12:30PM: Mathematical Issues in LQG. Chair: Jerzy Lewandowski (jerzy.lewandowski at fuw.edu.pl); Speakers: Jonathan Engle, Jose-Antonio Zapata and Daniel Cartin/Gaurav Khanna (20+10 each)

11. 2:00-3:30PM: Interface of Gravity, Thermodynamics and Cosmology . Chair: Warner Miller (wam at fau.edu); Rapporteurs: Ted Jacobson and Stephon Alexander (25+10, each)

12. 4:00PM-5:30PM: Discussion and Summary. Chair: Alejandro Corichi (corichi at nucleares.unam.mx); Speakers: ..., Ashtekar
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
would anyone be willing to go to Yidun Wan's blog
http://www.wanyidun.com/blog_r2u/?p=85#respond
and ask him to report a bit?Yidun is there all right. L.S. told him to get his self down to Penn State
and take in the conference.

===================

BTW according to what Francesca said, Lee Smolin is not going to conferences these days because
of two important arrivals----only one of which is that of his new book.
If that's so, it will be an unusual QG conference if only because of Smolin's absence.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Dear Marcus,
Thanks for your advertising! I wrote a "not a report" last night. I guess it is not so satisfactory to really curious people. link: http://www.wanyidun.com .
 
Last edited by a moderator:
lqg said:
Dear Marcus,
Thanks for your advertising! I wrote a "not a report" last night. I guess it is not so satisfactory to really curious people. link: http://www.wanyidun.com .

Yidun, thanks much!
I have not read your "Not-a" report yet. I will go do that now.
I hope you add to it, no matter how long it is!
Many of us have no window into that conference besides what you and others might blog about it.

regards,
M.

================
I read your blog and am delighted to learn that some audio of talks will be posted! I assume also PDF of lecture slides.
From past experience I can not believe that they will be posted within a week, however.

In your paragraph about Freidel's talk you may be making an accidental error similar to a typo.

"He tries formulate a generic framework of spin foam quantum gravity with qauntum field theory that recovers the classical gravity in 2+1 or 4+1 dimensions when G -> 0. This ..."

I think that in the zero gravity limit Freidel wants to recover USUAL QUANTUM FIELD THEORY---the field theory of usual Feynman diagrams for usual particle fields on a flat space.

I also believe he checks to see that he recovers classical gravity, but in another, different, limit. Maybe I am wrong but you might check to be sure. Also maybe you wrote 4+1 when you intended to write 3+1, but this doesn't matter much and indeed they seems to be always going up to 4+1 these days as a way of handling de-Sitter business.

thanks again for the report!
Please tell us when the lecture files are ready to listen to and watch.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Marcus,
Thanks for correcting the typo/mistakes for me. Yes, I did mean 3+1.:smile: Besides, I think Prof. Freidel wants to recover both QFT and GR. Since I paid too much attention to the inverse problem, I mistakenly wrote down GR in that case. I am going to correct them now.
 
great guy, I envy you that epic car trip + wide-ranging discussion reported on yr blog
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
6K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
7K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
5K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
4K