Tong Dynamics: cannot cancel angle from orbit energy expression calculation

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter jds17
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Energy Orbit
2 replies · 2K views · last reply
jds17
Messages
7
Reaction score
1
Hi, I love the lectures by David Tong. Usually I can follow his calculations (but I am not yet so far into the lectures...). But one that I just cannot do is the derivation of the energy in (4.16), the expression being ##E = \frac {mk^2} {2 l^2} (e^2 - 1)##, where l is the constant angular momentum of the orbit of the single point particle, m its mass, V(r) = - k/r the expression for the potential and e the eccentricity of the orbit.
I just don't see how using the expression ##\frac {dr} {d\theta} = \frac {r_0 e \sin(\theta)} {(1+e \cos(\theta))^2}## (page 59) in the expression of the energy using the effective potential cancels out the angle ##\theta##. Of course it has to work since the energy is a constant of motion, but no matter what trigonometric manipulations I use, it does not cancel out the angle.
In case it is not so readable I have attached the relevant sections from the lecture
 
Attachments
  • Printed page 59 from a physics text, section The Energy of the Orbit Revisited, showing the orbit energy E = (1/2)m(dr/dθ)^2 θdot^2 + ml^2/(2r^2) - k/r, rewritten with l^2/r^4 and then the expression dr/dθ = r0 e sin θ / (1 + e cos θ)^2.
    IMG_20240910_232116.jpg
    32.3 KB · Views: 99
  • Printed text from a physics textbook: 'After a couple of lines of algebra, we find that all the θ dependence vanishes in the energy (as it must since the energy is a constant of the motion). We are left with the pleasingly simple result' followed by the equation E = (mk²/2l²)(e² − 1), labelled (4.16).
    IMG_20240910_232129.jpg
    17 KB · Views: 88
Last edited:
Are you cancelling units or dimensions?
An angle is a ratio, it has no dimension.
 
Thanks! I know, the angle is dimensionless, but still the energy cannot depend on the angle.

I just found why I could not continue with the calculation: I left the radius r in the expression for the energy, but I need to expand it in terms of r_0, theta and the eccentricity as well! It is getting late here. I will do the calculation tomorrow.