Track Movement of Spherical Mass with 3 Contact Points

  • Thread starter Thread starter Kekrozz
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Movement Tracking
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the dynamics of a spherical mass supported by three contact points, specifically focusing on the rotation of the sphere initiated by a driver wheel. Participants explore the equations of motion, the effects of friction, and the conditions under which slipping occurs during the system's startup phase.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes the system's configuration and seeks to understand the dynamics of the sphere's rotation in relation to the driver wheel's torque.
  • Another participant provides equations of motion for the driver, sphere, and conical supports, suggesting that the system can be solved with the given equations.
  • A question is raised regarding the assumption of no slipping in the relationship between angular accelerations of the sphere and driver.
  • One participant argues that at the contact point, the acceleration is the same for both the sphere and the driver, assuming no slipping.
  • Another participant introduces the concept of frictional force and its role when the system is at rest and begins to rotate.
  • A subsequent participant emphasizes that during the initial rotation, the transmitted force must exceed the frictional force to initiate motion, indicating that slipping occurs at the start.
  • Further elaboration is provided on the equations governing the system when slipping occurs, detailing the conditions under which different components of the system interact.
  • One participant challenges the feasibility of the proposed model, suggesting it may not adequately describe the transient phase of the system as it reaches dynamic equilibrium.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the role of friction and the conditions for slipping during the startup phase. There is no consensus on the adequacy of the proposed model to describe the dynamics of the system during this transient period.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include the dependence on assumptions regarding slipping and friction, as well as the potential inadequacy of the model to capture the dynamics during the initial startup phase of the system.

Kekrozz
Messages
9
Reaction score
1
Hello! I'm having a little problem to figure out the rotation of a spherical mass, maybe you have more clear ideas!
Imagine to have a sphere laying (just it weight) on a support with three contact point:
1) one wheel, that has an external torque apply.
2) helping support that touch the sphere in two point with two conical wheels (one shaft mounting two conical wheels).

I would like to rotate the sphere, just with the rotation of the driver wheel.
Also I would like to know the rotation of the test mass, driver wheel and helping wheels.
I know, of course that if the applied torque is less than a certain value there is the pure rotation without sliding, so I am able to relate the rotation of the driver to the rotation of the others.

My question regards the start on of the system.
Is it possible to find equation that describe the dynamics of the start on of the system?
If I have a slide in some contact I'm not able anymore to know the exact rotation of the sphere because I can't not relate it to the driver rotation.
Sorry if it difficult to understand what I wrote, if you have question just tell me!
Thanks!
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
I'm not sure if this is what you are asking, but these are the equations of motion for the system:

For the driver:
[tex]T_{d\ in} - T_{d\ out} = I_d\alpha_d[/tex]
For the sphere:
[tex]T_{s\ in} - T_{s\ out} = I_s\alpha_s[/tex]
For the conical supports (assuming both are identical):
[tex]T_{c\ in} = 2I_c\alpha_c[/tex]
Furthermore:
[tex]\alpha_s r_s = \alpha_d r_d[/tex]
[tex]\alpha_c r_c = \alpha_s r_s[/tex]
[tex]\frac{T_{d\ out}} {r_d} = \frac{T_{s\ in}} {r_s}[/tex]
[tex]\frac{T_{s\ out}} {r_s} = \frac{T_{c\ in}} {r_c}[/tex]
##T## is torque, ##I## is moment of inertia, ##\alpha## is angular acceleration, ##r## is radius.

That is 7 equations with 7 unknowns (##T_{d\ out}, \alpha_d, T_{s\ in}, T_{s\ out}, \alpha_s, T_{c\ in}, \alpha_c##), so this system of equations can be solved.

Of course, in addition, the angular velocities (##\omega##) relations are:
[tex]\omega_s r_s = \omega_d r_d[/tex]
[tex]\omega_c r_c = \omega_s r_s[/tex]
 
why the αsrs=αdrd should be equal? you are already supposing the no skid with this equation?
 
Because at the contact point, assuming no slipping, the acceleration is the same for both the sphere and the driver (##a_s = a_d##).
 
I realize now that you want to know what happens if there is slipping. Then, you have to consider the friction force between the driver and the sphere (##F_{ds}##):
[tex]T_{d\ in} = F_{ds}r_d[/tex]
Or:
[tex]T_{d\ in} = \mu N r_d[/tex]
Where ##N## is the normal force between the sphere and the driver.
 
Yes of course, but at time zero when the system, is starting to rotate, in the contact point there is the frictional force (the system is initially at rest), so first of all the transmitted force has be bigger than the frictional force to activate the rotation, in that particular instant, for the mathematical model, there is skid, am I right?
If this is right you are not able to track the rotation of the sphere whenever you want.
Is it correct? I'm getting confused about the role of the friction force when a system at rest start to rotate.
 
If ##T_{d\ in} \gt (\mu N)_{ds} r_d##, then there is slip between the driver and the sphere:

The driver (1 equation, 1 unknown):
[tex]T_{d\ in} - (\mu N)_{ds} r_d = I_d\alpha_d[/tex]
The sphere + supports, no slip (4 equations, 4 unknowns):
[tex](\mu N)_{ds} r_s - T_{s\ out} = I_s\alpha_s[/tex]
[tex]T_{c\ in} = 2I_c\alpha_c[/tex]
[tex]\alpha_c r_c = \alpha_s r_s[/tex]
[tex]\frac{T_{s\ out}} {r_s} = \frac{T_{c\ in}} {r_c}[/tex]
If ##T_{s\ out} \gt (\mu N)_{ds} r_s##, then there is slip between the sphere and the supports:

The sphere (1 equation, 1 unknown):
[tex](\mu N)_{ds} r_s - (\mu N)_{sc} r_s = I_s\alpha_s[/tex]
The supports (1 equation, 1 unknown):
[tex](\mu N)_{sc} r_c = 2I_c\alpha_c[/tex]
 
I think this is not feasible, in with way you are saying that the Conical support receive
(μN)scrc moment, but actually it has to receive the tangential force due to the rotation of the test mass, also I think that this model is able to explain what happens in steady rotation, but is not describing the "shut on" of the system, so the little transitory time in which the system is settling down and came to an dynamic equilibrium.
 

Similar threads

Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 24 ·
Replies
24
Views
4K