Troubleshooting Inverse Function Problem | Basic Algebra Review

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
2 replies · 2K views
aquitaine
Messages
30
Reaction score
9
Ok, I decided to review basic algebra since I haven't done anything with it in like, forever. I came across an inverse function problem that I can't get the right answer.

the equation is:

y = cuberoot(x+sqrt(1+x^2)) + cuberoot(x-sqrt(1+x^2))

I tried replacing X with Y, and solving for Y
and getting rid of the cube roots by cubing both sides
X^3 = y + sqrt(1+y^2) + y - sqrt(1+y^2)
simplifying a bit (the square roots go away)
x^3 = 2y
so
y = (1/2)x^3

Yet the book I'm using says the answer is y=(1/2)(3x+x^3)

What did I do wrong?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
aquitaine said:
Ok, I decided to review basic algebra since I haven't done anything with it in like, forever. I came across an inverse function problem that I can't get the right answer.

the equation is:

y = cuberoot(x+sqrt(1+x^2)) + cuberoot(x-sqrt(1+x^2))

I tried replacing X with Y, and solving for Y
and getting rid of the cube roots by cubing both sides
X^3 = y + sqrt(1+y^2) + y - sqrt(1+y^2)
simplifying a bit (the square roots go away)
x^3 = 2y
so
y = (1/2)x^3

Yet the book I'm using says the answer is y=(1/2)(3x+x^3)

What did I do wrong?

Your equation is a tad confusing, you have y = [tex]\sqrt[3]{x+sqrt(1+x^2)}[/tex] + [tex]\sqrt[3]{x-sqrt(1+x^2)}[/tex]

then you cube both sides and switch y's and x's to get [tex]x^{3}[/tex] = y+[tex]\sqrt(1+y^2)[/tex] + y-[tex]\sqrt(1+y^2)[/tex]

Which is wrong. Now if your equation was y = [tex]\sqrt[3]{x+\sqrt(1+x^2)+x-\sqrt(1+x^2)}[/tex] this method would be correct. However, it would have been simplified easily before you even cube both sides; In this case it would be in the form y = [tex]\sqrt[3]{2x}[/tex] for the roots cancel automatically.
 
Last edited: