Understanding Gas Laws: Explaining the Relationship Between Pressure and Volume

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around understanding gas laws, specifically Gay Lussac's and Boyle's laws, and their implications on pressure and volume relationships. A participant expresses confusion about how volume can remain constant while temperature changes affect pressure, and how these relationships are mathematically represented. Clarifications are provided regarding the behavior of gas in different containers, such as balloons and rigid containers, and the effects of heating gas. The conversation highlights the importance of understanding direct and inverse relationships in mathematical terms, emphasizing the need for proper foundational knowledge in physical sciences. Overall, the thread illustrates the challenges faced by students in grasping complex scientific concepts and the value of self-study resources.
D4rk
Messages
9
Reaction score
1
Hey guys. I'm new to the forum :). I'm a high school student who takes physical sciences as one of my subject. The thing is that I've been confused about something I read on chemistry. This might sound stupid but please try and understand that this is confusing me.

In the gas laws, Gay Lussac's law states that: " The pressure of a fixed amount of gas at
constant volume is proportional to its absolute temperature". Where in Boyle's law it states that: "The volume of a fixed amount of gas is proportional to its pressure at constant temperature".

My question is that since the amount of pressure effects the amount of volume, How can the volume be kept at a constant when the temperature causes a change in pressure ( which in turn effects volume)?

Also why is a direct relationship expressed as P/T and an inverse relationship expressed as PV=PV?
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
D4rk said:
How can the volume be kept at a constant when the temperature causes a change in pressure

You can keep gas in a balloon (which will inflate or deflate) or in a rigid container, which will not change its volume.

Also why is a direct relationship expressed as P/T and an inverse relationship expressed as PV=PV?

Please elaborate.
 
Borek said:
You can keep gas in a balloon (which will inflate or deflate) or in a rigid container, which will not change its volume.
Ah, I see. Thanks for the reply. I thought that it might be so, but I was confused by some other ideas. Like if the container has a hole in it, does that make it harder to increase the pressure inside the container itself?

I think I'm beginning to get it now. Would this then be a logical explanation for why a balloon pops when exposed to a heat source: The gas molecules around the balloon have an increase in pressure due to increase in temperature, while the gas molecules inside the balloon have a lower pressure because of the lower temperature. Eventually the pressure outside is great enough to crush the inner pressure.

Please elaborate.
I just read an explanation on wikipedia, so I think I'm fine on that. Thanks though.
 
D4rk said:
Ah, I see. Thanks for the reply. I thought that it might be so, but I was confused by some other ideas. Like if the container has a hole in it, does that make it harder to increase the pressure inside the container itself?

If there is a hole, gas escapes, so you are no longer dealing with the same amount of gas.

I think I'm beginning to get it now. Would this then be a logical explanation for why a balloon pops when exposed to a heat source: The gas molecules around the balloon have an increase in pressure due to increase in temperature, while the gas molecules inside the balloon have a lower pressure because of the lower temperature. Eventually the pressure outside is great enough to crush the inner pressure.

It is not clear to me what is the scenario you are trying to describe. If you heat the gas inside of the balloon, it expands till the balloon pops. If you heat the balloon surface locally, you make a hole and the balloon pops. If you put balloon in the warm air, it will slowly heat up and expand - till it pops.
 
Also why is a direct relationship expressed as P/T and an inverse relationship expressed as PV=PV?

A relationship keeps the same ratio of variables. If one variable increases so does the other.

An inverses relationship keeps the product of the variables constant, so if one variable goes up the other variable must decrease.

This is basic mathematics.
You should review your graphs of equations starting with y=mx +b ( direct relationship ), and continue on with inverse functions, logarithic, exponential, power, sine, etc. A specific "look" to a graph comes in handy when you are plotting data points from a chemistry or physics experiment, and you can then surmise the functioning equation between your variables of the experiment.
 
Borek said:
If there is a hole, gas escapes, so you are no longer dealing with the same amount of gas.

It is not clear to me what is the scenario you are trying to describe. If you heat the gas inside of the balloon, it expands till the balloon pops. If you heat the balloon surface locally, you make a hole and the balloon pops. If you put balloon in the warm air, it will slowly heat up and expand - till it pops.
*Sigh*, I hate the fact that my teachers are so crap. I have to pull through with self studying. Thanks for explaining this to me.

256bits said:
.
This is basic mathematics.
You should review your graphs of equations starting with y=mx +b ( direct relationship ), and continue on with inverse functions, logarithic, exponential, power, sine, etc. A specific "look" to a graph comes in handy when you are plotting data points from a chemistry or physics experiment, and you can then surmise the functioning equation between your variables of the experiment.
Unfortunately, I wasn't really paying attention in class when we were discussing the straight line graph. Also the biggest problem that I have in school at the moment is that the teachers never explain properly, you can clearly see that some of them don't know their stuff. I'll have a look on it though, I found the internet to be bliss with multitudes of helpful tutorials.
 
I want to test a humidity sensor with one or more saturated salt solutions. The table salt that I have on hand contains one of two anticaking agents, calcium silicate or sodium aluminosilicate. Will the presence of either of these additives (or iodine for that matter) significantly affect the equilibrium humidity? I searched and all the how-to-do-it guides did not address this question. One research paper I found reported that at 1.5% w/w calcium silicate increased the deliquescent point by...
Back
Top