Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the selection of universities for pursuing a PhD in physics, with participants sharing their thoughts on the application process, the importance of providing detailed background information, and the implications of the OP's previous rejections. The conversation touches on various universities in the US and Europe, as well as the potential risks associated with certain institutions.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Meta-discussion
Main Points Raised
- Some participants emphasize the need for the OP to provide more details about their background and previous applications to receive meaningful advice.
- There are concerns about the perceived risks of applying to certain universities, particularly in Belarus and Russia, with some arguing that these risks may not apply to the OP depending on their nationality.
- Participants discuss the importance of follow-through in the application process, suggesting that a lack of it may have contributed to the OP's previous rejections.
- Some express skepticism about the OP's communication style, questioning whether it may negatively impact their application.
- There is a mention of the OP's activity on other platforms, indicating that they may not be engaging effectively with the advice given.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally agree that more information from the OP is necessary for a productive discussion. However, there are competing views regarding the risks associated with certain universities and the implications of the OP's communication style.
Contextual Notes
Limitations include a lack of information about the OP's background, previous applications, and the specific universities they are considering. The discussion also reflects varying opinions on the appropriateness of the OP's communication style in the context of graduate applications.