Verifying Lie Bracket for Vector Fields on U

In summary, if we have a vector field vect on a manifold, and the bracket of two vector fields in v and w is defined in coordinates, then the components of [v,w] are given by [v,w]:=(\sum_{i,j}( V^{i} \frac{d}{dx}X^{i} W^{j} - W^{i} \frac{d}{dx}X^{i} V^{j} ) \frac{d}{dx}]. If the definition is independent of the choice of coordinates, it is bilinear by nature. The jacobi identity yields [v,[u,w]] = [[v,u
  • #1
If we have vect (u) which denotes an infinite-dimensional vector space of all vector fields on u. As infinitesimal elements of the continuous group of Diff(u) they form a Lie Algebra. We then can define the bracket of two vector fields in v and w. If in coordinates:

v = [tex]\sum_{i}[/tex]V i [tex]\partial[/tex][tex]/[/tex][tex]\partial[/tex]X[tex]^{i}[/tex]

w = [tex]\sum_{j}[/tex]Wj [tex]\partial[/tex][tex]/[/tex] [tex]\partial[/tex]X[tex]^{j}[/tex]

the components of [v,w]

[v,w]:=[tex](\sum_{i,j}([/tex] [tex]V^{i}[/tex] [tex]\frac{d}{dx}[/tex][tex]X^{i}[/tex] [tex]W^{j}[/tex] - [tex]W^{i}[/tex] [tex]\frac{d}{dx}[/tex][tex]X^{i}[/tex] [tex]V^{j} )[/tex] [tex]\frac{d}{dx}[/tex]

if the definition is independent of the choice of coordinates is it bilinear by nature? if so it must be antisymmetric [v,w] = -[w,v];

therefore the jacobi identity would yield [v,[u,w]] = [[v,u],w] + [u, [v,w]]

how can i go about verifying this for a lie bracket?
Last edited:
Physics news on
  • #2
You know that


where Xf is defined as the function that takes p to [itex]X_pf[/itex], right? So why not just use this on [itex][U,[V,W]][/itex]? When you have your result, just substitute U→V→W→U to get a new equation, and then do it again to get a third. Then add the three equations together.

You might be interested in this thread too, if not for anything else, just to see how to LaTeX these things. Click on the math expression or quote the post to see the LaTeX code.
Last edited:
  • #3
oh, thank you, I believe I got incredibly confused by trying to relate the 0-forms to any p-form. e.g: let's say i have a linear map

D: [tex]\Lambda^{p}U \rightarrow \Lambda^{p+d}U[/tex]

if I were to take a graded derivation of [tex]\Lambda\U[/tex] of degree d [tex]\in Z[/tex]

if it satisfies,

[tex] D(\varphi \wedge \Psi ) = ( D \varphi ) \wedge \Psi + ( -1)^{d deg \varphi} \varphi\wedge D\varphi [/tex]

the set of all graded derivations of [tex] \Lambda U [/tex] is an infinite-dimensional graded lie algebra with a bracket:

[tex] [D_{1}, D_{2}]: = D_{1}D_{2} - ( -1) ^{d_{1} d_{2} [/tex] [tex] D_{2} D_{1} } [/tex]

and then I can evaluate the Inner Lie, and exterior derivative togheter to form a graded subalgebra, then probably use Cartan's method of commutation relation (where U is equipped with an orientation and a metric.)
Last edited:
  • #4
I have another question though:

How can I verify the lie bracket of two vector fields on a manifold using the method you transcribed?
Last edited:
  • #5
I don't understand. What do you want to verify? That the commutator is a Lie bracket? Are you asking for the details of the derivation I sketched? Have you tried and got stuck somewhere?
  • #6
What I am trying to do is prove mathematically the existence of vector fields on open subsets of [tex]\textbf{R}^{n}[/tex]. Assuming the tangent space and vector fields lie on differentiable manifold M. Identifying these vector fields would allow me to start defining the tangent vectors on the manifold.

Let [tex] (U, \alpha) [/tex] be a chart for M and denote the corresponding coordinates by [tex] X^{1}, X^{2}, ... X^{n} [/tex]


[tex] f : U \rightarrow \textbf{R} [/tex]

be differentiable at [tex] x \in U[/tex].

[tex] f \circ \alpha ^{-1} : \alpha (U) \rightarrow \textbf{R} [/tex]

which is differentiable at [tex]\alpha (x)[/tex].

[tex] \frac{\partial}{\partial_x^{i}} |_{x} f: =\frac{\partial}{\partial^{i}}( f \circ\alpha^{-1}|_{\alpha (x)} = \frac{\partial}{\partial \(x)^{i}} f ( x^{1}, \x^{2}, \...\x^{n}. [/tex]

satisfying liebniz:

[tex] \frac{\partial}{\partial^{i}}|_{x} (f\g) = (\frac{\partial}{\partial^{i}}|_{x} f ) g(x) + f(x) \frac{\partial}{\partial^{i}} |_{x} \\\\\\g, [/tex]

where f and g are differentiable at x. Is my reasoning correct?
  • #7
Looks like you need to work on your LaTeX skills. :smile: Click the quote buttons or the math in my posts here to see how I wrote similar expressions. I also suggest that you preview before you post.

If you just want to show that local vector fields exist, by showing that a partial derivative operator [itex]\partial_i[/itex] is a local vector field, all you need to show is that [itex]p\mapsto\partial_i|_pf[/itex] is smooth for every smooth f. (Edit: This is assuming that we already know that [itex]\partial_i|_p[/itex] is a tangent vector at p. See Isham's book if you don't). The thing on the right there is defined as [itex](f\circ\alpha^{-1})_{,i}(\alpha(p))[/itex], where I'm using the notation ",i" for the ith partial derivative. Now what do we mean when we say that f is smooth? It means precisely that [itex]f\circ\alpha^{-1}[/itex] is smooth for every coordinate system (chart) [itex]\alpha[/itex]. And when we have realized that, we're already done with the proof.

Isham's book is a really good place to read about tangent vectors. Lee is good too.
Last edited:

1. What is the Lie bracket for vector fields on U?

The Lie bracket for vector fields on U is a mathematical operation that measures the extent to which two vector fields do not commute with each other. It is also known as the Lie derivative or the commutator bracket, and is denoted by [X, Y].

2. How is the Lie bracket calculated?

The Lie bracket for vector fields on U is calculated by taking the commutator of the two vector fields, which is the difference between the two vector fields when they are applied in different orders. In mathematical notation, it can be represented as [X, Y] = X(Y) - Y(X).

3. What does the Lie bracket tell us about vector fields on U?

The Lie bracket provides information about the behavior of vector fields on U. It tells us how much the vector fields do not commute with each other, which can be used to analyze the flow of vector fields and their interactions.

4. Is the Lie bracket commutative?

No, the Lie bracket for vector fields on U is not commutative. This means that [X, Y] is not equal to [Y, X]. In other words, the order in which the vector fields are applied matters when calculating the Lie bracket.

5. What are some applications of the Lie bracket for vector fields on U?

The Lie bracket for vector fields on U has many applications in mathematics and physics. It is used to study the dynamics of systems, such as in fluid mechanics and control theory. It also plays a key role in the theory of differential equations and Lie groups.

Similar threads

  • Differential Geometry
  • Differential Geometry
  • Differential Geometry
  • Linear and Abstract Algebra
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
  • Special and General Relativity
  • Electromagnetism
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
  • Special and General Relativity