Discussion Overview
The thread discusses the annual vote for the Breakthrough of the Year organized by Science Magazine, highlighting various scientific advancements from 2018. Participants express their preferences among the listed breakthroughs and share opinions on the significance of these discoveries.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Exploratory
Main Points Raised
- Some participants express a preference for the impact crater discovery in Greenland, citing the long-term data collection involved.
- Others favor the "fly brain revealed" breakthrough, emphasizing its potential to open new avenues in neuroscience.
- Some participants mention that none of the listed breakthroughs resonate with them, suggesting alternative advancements they consider significant.
- There are discussions regarding the reliability of claims about orangutans communicating about the past, with some participants expressing skepticism and seeking references.
- A few participants highlight the significance of "development cell by cell," arguing it has broader applications in biology and may have a greater impact than other breakthroughs.
- One participant compares the impact of single transcriptomics in biology to the detection of gravitational waves in physics, suggesting its transformative potential.
- Some participants note the relevance of the #MeToo movement in science, questioning its connection to the breakthroughs listed.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally express multiple competing views regarding their favorite breakthroughs, with no consensus on a single choice. Various opinions on the significance and reliability of the breakthroughs are presented, indicating an unresolved discussion.
Contextual Notes
Some claims about the breakthroughs lack detailed references or established consensus on their implications. Discussions about the reliability of certain scientific claims remain open-ended, and the significance of breakthroughs is subject to individual interpretation.
Who May Find This Useful
Readers interested in recent scientific advancements, debates on the significance of breakthroughs in various fields, and discussions surrounding the implications of scientific discoveries may find this thread informative.