Wasd vs esdf pc game controls

In summary: So, every time someone new plays a video game, they have to relearn the controls because the default controls are for WASD, but most people prefer using the ESDF keys. For many years, I would bind the movement to the arrow keys, but I now prefer using the WASD keys because they're more comfortable. I also use the shift and ctrl keys to crouch and walk. It's interesting to note that many people use different controls, but ESDF is perfectly fine.
  • #1
DivergentSpectrum
149
15
So, every time i get a new game i have to change the controls, because the default controls for moving are wasd, but i prefer esdf.
To me wasd makes no sense. first off, esdf are the home row keys so my fingers naturally go towards those. the only way this could possibly make sense is if you used ring for w and s, pinky for a, and middle for d. i prefer to use my middle, ring, and index though because theyre more coordinated/stronger.

So i was wondering, when you play a pc game (usually fps), do you use custom controls?
Also for the people who use the default controls, how do you do it? do you ever try to move and notice you arent pressing the right keys? does it interfere with your typing skills?
does anyone know the reason for this?
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
  • #3
I use the WASD keys but shift my left hand over 1 key to the left, using the pinky finger for shift or control, mostly for some of the Tomb Raider series of games, which have a lot of other commands that I map to keys I can reach with the left hand, since the right hand is using the mouse and 2 or 3 mouse buttons.
 
  • #4
I use WASD, which is/are usually the default keybindings for the game. But it's not for any good reason, besides familiarity and laziness I suppose.

Switching to ESDF might have some advantages: yes, since I often find myself with fingers over the "wrong" keys (ESDF) causing the player character to exhibit symptoms of doing terribly incorrect things. I chalk it up to my character having issues with muscle spasms and maybe even seizures.

I usually stick with the default keybindings for the most part. Sometimes I'll switch the aim-down-sights control to the right mouse button if it's not there by default, but that's usually it (I'm pretty sure I had to do that for Bioshock Infinite). Then I'll just learn the new keybindings for the particular game.

That's one of the reasons I was so upset with Far Cry 3, a couple of years ago. In various parts of the main-story campaign missions, the game would suddenly switch which keys did what (even by default), when the game changed to a frustrating, quick-time-event format. I don't know what the developers were thinking. It was a slap in the face to the otherwise, very good game mechanics. (Fortunately I haven't seen this in Far Cry 4*, but I haven't finished the game yet -- but I'm led to believe that remapping the keybindings might break the game when it comes to rope climbing.)

*[Edit: One common mistake I've made several times so far in Far Cry 4 is when attempting to gently climb on top an elephant to ride it, I accidentally take out my knife and slash the elephant in the gut (muscle spasm, I guess). This has the unfortunate effect of infuriating the elephant. Things go downhill after that.]
 
Last edited:
  • #5
wow 3 WASD'ers and I am the only user of ESDF?
crazy. i think my first fps was quake, and back then I am pretty sure i used arrow keys for movement.
then i started playing tribes, and i believe i have that game to thank for my correct gaming style (apparently it was one of the few fps that had ESDF for default movement.)

If i ever come over to play vidya games with you guys, I am changing your settings. :P

just curious, i went to http://10fastfingers.com/typing-test/english
i scored 52 wpm with one word wrong the first try. (better than 76% of the people who take it) what kinds of scores do you get?

Man if i was a typing teacher i would be so pissed off lol
 
  • #6
rcgldr said:
[...] mostly for some of the Tomb Raider series of games, [...]
Speaking of which, I couldn't tell you how many times, years ago, when I tried to get Lara Croft to sneak along the top of a rock-face only to have her inadvertently do a swan dive into the spiky rocks below. "Really, Lara? A swan dive?"
 
  • #8
What nobody uses VIM bindings?!
 
  • Like
Likes TheDemx27 and collinsmark
  • #10
WASD makes more sense to me, since many games use left shift/left ctrl all the time, and centering the hand over WASD (middle finger for W/S, ring and index for A and D respectively) positions the little finger nicely over left shift and left ctrl. In addition, E and F are often used for actions in game, and they're convenient with the index finger when the hand is centered over WASD. Sure, it isn't the standard typing hand positioning, but why should your gaming hand position necessarily be identical to typing?

Oh, and for what it's worth...

78_392_0_0_77_1_90.86_14643_160273.png
 

1. What is the difference between WASD and ESDF game controls?

WASD is a popular keyboard control scheme where the keys W, A, S, and D are used to move the character or camera in a game. ESDF, on the other hand, uses the keys E, S, D, and F for movement. The main difference is that ESDF allows for additional keys to be easily reached for other game commands.

2. Which control scheme is better for gaming?

This is a matter of personal preference and depends on the individual's comfort and familiarity with the keys. Some may find WASD more intuitive, while others may prefer the extra key options provided by ESDF.

3. Can I change the game controls from WASD to ESDF or vice versa?

Yes, most games allow you to customize the controls to your liking. Check the game's settings or options menu to see if this is an option.

4. Are there any advantages to using ESDF over WASD?

Some players believe that ESDF offers better hand positioning and ergonomics, as it keeps the hand closer to the center of the keyboard. It also allows for easier access to additional keys, potentially giving players an advantage in certain games.

5. Are there any disadvantages to using ESDF controls?

The main disadvantage of using ESDF is that it may take some time for players to get used to the new key placement, especially if they are used to using WASD. This could lead to a temporary decrease in performance until the player becomes comfortable with the new controls.

Similar threads

  • Computing and Technology
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Computing and Technology
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
951
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
607
Replies
9
Views
872
  • General Discussion
Replies
5
Views
685
  • Programming and Computer Science
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
2K
Back
Top