What are the highlights of the new book of letters from Richard Feynman?

  • Thread starter Thread starter infidel
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Book Feynman
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the new book of letters from Richard Feynman, titled "Perfectly Reasonable Deviations from the Beaten Track," edited by his daughter, Michelle Feynman. Participants share their experiences related to the book, including a book signing event, and express their thoughts on the content and implications of publishing Feynman's personal letters.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes attending a book signing event where Michelle Feynman read letters and engaged with attendees, highlighting the emotional depth of the letters, particularly regarding Feynman's relationship with his first wife, Arline.
  • Another participant mentions reading about 100 pages of the book and finds it interesting, especially the portrayal of Feynman's personal life during the Los Alamos era.
  • A different participant expresses a positive view of Feynman's previous works and indicates interest in the new book, although they note a lack of nearby book tour events.
  • Some participants question the appropriateness of publishing Feynman's personal letters, suggesting it may be motivated by profit or a desire to share his legacy with those who never met him.
  • One participant argues that Feynman's life is already public and that many letters would eventually be published, while also acknowledging a potential financial motive behind the publication.
  • Another participant shares a personal reaction to Feynman's letters, indicating a strong emotional response to the content, particularly a letter addressed to his deceased wife.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express mixed feelings about the publication of Feynman's letters, with some supporting it as a means of sharing his legacy and others questioning the motivations behind it. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the appropriateness of such publications.

Contextual Notes

Some participants reference the emotional and personal nature of the letters, noting that Feynman's life experiences, including intimate moments, are already part of the public domain. There is also mention of previously published letters and their impact on readers.

infidel
Messages
56
Reaction score
0
I went to a book signing tonight for a new volume of letters to and from Richard Feynman entitled Perfectly Reasonable Deviations from the Beaten Track.

The book is edited by Michelle Feynman, Richard's daughter. She gave a brief introduction to the book and then read several of the letters. Then she answered a few questions before commencing to sign the books.

She was a beautiful, intelligent, and well-spoken woman who obviously loves her father and was, as she said, surprised and touched by many of the letters. As she points out, most of his popular 'works' stem from the spoken word, either lectures or anecdotes. Here we see Feynman writing, and well.

I had a lot of fun and she took time to talk a bit to each of the 20 or so people who came up for a signing. She asked me if I was a physicist (!). I told her no, but that her father was an intellectual hero of mine for many years. She signed the book, "To Dan, From your hero's daughter. Best wishes. Michelle Feynman." Very nice.

Well since I got home I've read about 100 pages of the book, all through the Los Alamos era. Very interesting and highly recommended to Feynman fans. Others might find it a bit too esoteric. One thing that always touched me about Feynman was the fateful story of his love for his first wife, Arline, and her struggle with and eventual death due to TB. This period comes out beautifully in the book. (For more on that, rent the fabulous movie Infinity, about this period of his life.)

You can find dates for other signings at http://www.basicfeynman.com, including "authorless events" where instead of Michelle, a panel of Feynman's friends and co-workers will talk about his legacy. I'm attending one in NYC on May 2 which includes Freeman Dyson.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
infidel said:
Well since I got home I've read about 100 pages of the book, all through the Los Alamos era. Very interesting and highly recommended to Feynman fans. Others might find it a bit too esoteric. One thing that always touched me about Feynman was the fateful story of his love for his first wife, Arline, and her struggle with and eventual death due to TB. This period comes out beautifully in the book. (For more on that, rent the fabulous movie Infinity, about this period of his life.)
I was just re-reading "Surely You Must be Joking" last night. The stories of his (frequently interepted and censored!) communication with his wife while he was in New Mexico were funny and very touching. I'll have to get this book.
 
That’s one of my favorite books Math is Hard. I did not know who Feynman when I first read the book. A good read for anyone imo.

I will have to check out he new book infidel thanks for pointing it out. I did not see any tours coming close to me, probably for the best I would not have time to go to it anyway.
 
Does anyone think that the post-humous publications of Feynman's letters are a little to personal to be published and that perhaps it is just a way to produce money or do you think it is just a way to allow people who never had the chance to meet him to know how he was like?
 
quasi426 said:
Does anyone think that the post-humous publications of Feynman's letters are a little to personal to be published and that perhaps it is just a way to produce money or do you think it is just a way to allow people who never had the chance to meet him to know how he was like?


I don't think it's too personal, given that Feynmann's life, including its most intimate moments, is already in the public domain. The tragic story of him and Arlene was made into the movie "Infinity". The famous letter to "d-Arlene" has already been published.

Most of the letters are of the kind that would eventually be published anyway; his reactions to the Nobel prize, his break with the National Academy, his work on science schoolbooks, all are of definite interest.

But yes, I do think there was some idea on the part of his children to cash in on the "Feynmann phenomenon", which is making a bundle for others.
 
I gathered this was due since The Guardian published a selection of them a couple of weeks ago. Even my science-hating girlfriend was enraptured. I'm a fairly poker-faced man, but his letter to his dead wife broke my heart. I will be getting this ASAP. Hmm, birthday coming up.
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
23
Views
9K
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 204 ·
7
Replies
204
Views
41K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
7K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
6K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
6K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
6K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K