What are the names of surfaces that are tangent to a vector field?

  • Context: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Thread starter BobbyBear
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Surface
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers on the terminology used for surfaces that are tangent to a vector field at each point, exploring concepts from fluid mechanics and differential geometry. Participants inquire about general names for such surfaces and specific terms when the vector field is the curl of another vector field.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant suggests that surfaces tangent to a vector field are called stream surfaces in fluid mechanics.
  • Another participant mentions that in calculus, such surfaces are referred to as integral surfaces of the vector field, relating this to Frobenius' Theorem.
  • It is proposed that surfaces tangent to the curl of a vector field are called vortex tubes.
  • A different perspective is offered regarding the tangent bundle of an n-manifold and its relation to vector fields and integral manifolds.
  • A participant expresses uncertainty about terms like manifold, Lie bracket, and bundle, opting to use integral surface for surfaces tangent to a vector field.
  • There is a suggestion that characteristic curves tangent to the vector field can be analogously referred to as streamlines, and surfaces formed by these curves as stream-tubes or stream-surfaces.
  • Lev Elsgolts is cited for naming curves tangent to the curl of a vector field as vortex lines and the surfaces they generate as vortex surfaces.
  • One participant summarizes the nomenclature, linking streamlines and vortex lines to their respective surfaces, while questioning if the terminology is appropriate.
  • Another participant confirms the use of integral surface and emphasizes that vortex lines and surfaces are specific examples, noting that not all vector fields are curls of another vector field.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express various viewpoints on the terminology, with some agreeing on terms like integral surfaces and vortex tubes, while others introduce additional concepts and clarify that not all vector fields fit the same definitions. The discussion remains unresolved regarding a universally accepted terminology.

Contextual Notes

Some participants acknowledge limitations in their understanding of advanced concepts such as manifolds and Lie brackets, which may affect their contributions to the discussion. The definitions and relationships between the terms used are not fully established, leading to potential ambiguity.

BobbyBear
Messages
162
Reaction score
1
Given a vector field, what do you call a surface such that the vector field is tangent to it at each point? I think in fluid mechanics they're called stream surfaces, but I just wondered if there's a name for them in general.

Also in particular, if the vector field in question is the curl of another vector field, is there any special name for surfaces such that the curl field is tangent to them at each point?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
In calculus such a surface is called an integral surface of the vector field. This idea generalizes to finite dimensional distributions on differentiable manifolds. The distribution can be integrated i.e. it is tangent to a sub-manifold iff it is closed under the Lie bracket. This is the Froebeiuns Theorem.

I think a surface tangent to the curl of a vector field is called a vortex tube.
 
Conversely,

Given any n-manifold, the union of the tangent spaces at each point gives you the tangent bundle which is of 2n dimension (since its elements are couples of n-dimensional points and n-dimensional vectors). If you take a cross section from your tangent bundle, at each point this gives you a single vector tangent to the manifold hence this cross section is a vector field.
 
Sina said:
Conversely,

Given any n-manifold, the union of the tangent spaces at each point gives you the tangent bundle which is of 2n dimension (since its elements are couples of n-dimensional points and n-dimensional vectors). If you take a cross section from your tangent bundle, at each point this gives you a single vector tangent to the manifold hence this cross section is a vector field.

Right. But I think the idea is used when applied to vector fields whose integral manifolds are proper submanifolds of a larger one. The spirit of the idea is to solve an ordinary differential equation and then find the submanifold that contains the flow lines. Vortex tubes are a classic example.
 
GUYS! thanks for all your replies:) Unfortunately, I don't know what a manifold is, what a lie bracket is, or what a bundle is :P

Okay I think I'll just go with integral surface to refer to a surface that is tangent to a vector field (eg the solution the PDE

<br /> P \frac{\partial\z}{\partial x} + Q \frac{\partial\z}{\partial y} = R<br />

are surfaces that are tangent at each point to the vector field (P,Q,R). These surfaces are made up of characteristic curves that are tangent at each point to the vector field. I'm not sure what you'd call these characteristic curves, but by analogy to fluid mechanics, I suppose one could call them streamlines. Streamlines passing through any closed curve (that is not a streamline itself) form a tubular surface called a stream-tube. If the curve is not closed, I suppose you could just call it a stream-surface.

Lev Elsgolts, in his book Differential Equations and the Calculus of Variations, calls the curves tangent to the curl of a vector field V, Vortex lines. And the surfaces generated by such curves, Vortex surfaces.

So I think in summary one can use the following nomenclature (even though it sounds like one is referring to fluid mechanics concepts rather than just in general):

let F = Curl V

Then the streamlines of F are the vortex lines of V.
The streamsurfaces of F are the vortex surfaces of V.
Streamlines passing through any closed curve form a tubular surface called a streamtube.
And likewise,
Vortex lines passing through any closed curve form a tubular surface called a vortex tube.

Is this okay then?

And in the same manner, if I just say integral surface, if I mean the surface tangent to F then I'd have to say integral surface of CurlV, right?
 
BobbyBear said:
GUYS! thanks for all your replies:) Unfortunately, I don't know what a manifold is, what a lie bracket is, or what a bundle is :P

Okay I think I'll just go with integral surface to refer to a surface that is tangent to a vector field (eg the solution the PDE

<br /> P \frac{\partial\z}{\partial x} + Q \frac{\partial\z}{\partial y} = R<br />

are surfaces that are tangent at each point to the vector field (P,Q,R). These surfaces are made up of characteristic curves that are tangent at each point to the vector field. I'm not sure what you'd call these characteristic curves, but by analogy to fluid mechanics, I suppose one could call them streamlines. Streamlines passing through any closed curve (that is not a streamline itself) form a tubular surface called a stream-tube. If the curve is not closed, I suppose you could just call it a stream-surface.

Lev Elsgolts, in his book Differential Equations and the Calculus of Variations, calls the curves tangent to the curl of a vector field V, Vortex lines. And the surfaces generated by such curves, Vortex surfaces.

So I think in summary one can use the following nomenclature (even though it sounds like one is referring to fluid mechanics concepts rather than just in general):

let F = Curl V

Then the streamlines of F are the vortex lines of V.
The streamsurfaces of F are the vortex surfaces of V.
Streamlines passing through any closed curve form a tubular surface called a streamtube.
And likewise,
Vortex lines passing through any closed curve form a tubular surface called a vortex tube.

Is this okay then?

And in the same manner, if I just say integral surface, if I mean the surface tangent to F then I'd have to say integral surface of CurlV, right?

Yes you are right. You should keep in mind thought that vortex lines and their surfaces are a special example - not every vector field is the curl of another yet all vector fields have integral surfaces.

In the books I learned from vortex surfaces were called vortex tubes.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 73 ·
3
Replies
73
Views
9K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
5K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
3K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
7K