- 2,704
- 19
What about C.S. Lewis? Anybody like his writings? I've read the Narnia books and the Space Trilogy. I got to say, I really enjoyed them.
Last edited:
shramana said:Lord of the rings is definitely much better than all the potter books put together. I think J.K. Rowling is losing her touch, the 5th and 6th books were sub-standard compared to the earlier ones.
what! ok, the 5th was kind of crap-ola, but the 6th was one of my favorites! and there have to be at least 7, you can't end the series before harry graduates.shramana said:the 5th and 6th books were sub-standard compared to the earlier ones.
G01 said:What about C.S. Lewis? Anybody like his writings? I've read the Narnia books and the Space Trilogy. I got to say, I really enjoyed them.
Integral said:The Witch, the Lion, and the Wardrobe was good each after that degraded to the point that the last was only good for toliet paper.
I am not sure why the Harry Potter books are always being held up to Tolkien. They are just different, I think both should be on the required reading list.
Fool of a Took rather!G01 said:blasphemer!![]()
siddharth said:I agree with both points. I also think that the Bartimaeus Trilogy by Jonathan Stroud should also be a part of the required reading list.
arunbg said:Fool of a Took rather!
Tolkien rules.

Yeah, it's called Earth.moe darklight said:it makes you a poor, lost soul forever to roam in some sort of neither hellish (tolkien) nor heavenly (rowling) limbo.
neutrino said:Yeah, it's called Earth.![]()

Smurf said:I've read both Tolkien and Rowling, and didn't like either. Can I be a double-Heretic?![]()
G01 said:What about C.S. Lewis? Anybody like his writings? I've read the Narnia books and the Space Trilogy. I got to say, I really enjoyed them.
Greg Bernhardt said:The God Dellusion
A Short History of Progress
Ever Wonder Why
I recommend them all, very good!
Math Is Hard said:I like C.S. Lewis. The Screwtape Letters is an especially good book.
Greg Bernhardt said:Looks like a nice pickup read for a long flight.