What Can You Do to Stop the Cruelty of Fur?

  • Thread starter Thread starter qspeechc
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary
The discussion centers around a graphic video depicting animal cruelty, particularly involving fur and meat production, which has sparked strong reactions among participants. Many express disgust at the footage, with some advocating for action against animal cruelty, while others debate the ethics of fur versus wool and leather. There is a notable division in opinions regarding PETA's stance, with some participants criticizing its methods and propaganda, while others acknowledge the importance of humane treatment of animals. The conversation also touches on personal experiences with animal products, including leather and wool, and the perceived aesthetics of fur fashion. Participants discuss the complexities of animal rights, human dietary needs, and the implications of various animal products, highlighting a range of ethical considerations in the treatment of animals for clothing and food.
  • #31
Seriously, what's wrong with fur?

>Is a lion ripping apart the innards of a gazelle not considered "cruelty" ?
>Or sharks tearing some herring in half not considered "cruelty" ? (so much for the "fish are friends not food" slogan)
>Why not show videos of those acts, and possibly run the "stop all carnivores" campaign?

*Edit: Alright, the "ethics" or "morality" of these acts (when humans are the carnivores in consideration?)
may well vary depending on the possible individual ethical contexts. Personally, I am rather Darwinian...
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
The PETA people don't get it. We humans are omnivores, and we evolved to eat a mix of vegetables, meats, etc. The food necessary for survival was obtained by hunting and gathering. Until the advent of agriculture, it may have been impossible for humans to get adequate protein from a plant-only diet.

I hunt deer, and I do it humanely, with a single-shot rifle and I will not take a shot unless it's a sure kill. The PETA people would probably call me a monster, but I feel a whole lot better eating meat from an animal that has spent its whole life in the wild, instead of eating beef from an animal that may never have been properly pastured with fresh green grass and water.

My wife and I buy Black Angus beef from a local farm that supplies plentiful pasture-space to their herd, with streams running through them, and farm-ponds to hold water in dry times. The cattle not only have fresh grass and water - they also get grain supplements and their pastures have plenty of trees so that they can find shade on hot days. This is a small family farm, and they are very conscientious and proud of the way they treat their animals. The quality of their free-range chickens beats anything you can get in a store. They had other projects going last summer (including expanding their huge strawberry fields) so they didn't raise chickens last summer. (Very sad!:cry:)
 
  • #33
Math Is Hard said:
I never wear fur. It's so passe. To me, women in fur coats look like hookers.
Agreed. I much prefer leather (for men and women).
 
  • #34
russ_watters said:
Agreed. I much prefer leather (for men and women).
Well, rides on the Softail generally involve sturdy leather boots and tough leather jacket for myself and my wife. Never been down since I gave up the hot 2-strokes, but if it ever happens, I want leather between me and the asphalt.
 
  • #35
For me, warmth trumps appearance for coats anyway. Turn the fur coat inside-out, and maybe I'll be happier with the result. I agree with MIH too that fur coats just look tacky, and ironically, cheap. But that's just aesthetics for me.
 
  • #36
What about down? If PETA were to succeed in banning fur (unlikely), then leather, then wool, wouldn't goose down be next? If they try to take away my sleeping bags and mountain coats, it's war!
 
  • #37
Er, I think some people miss the point- it's the treatment of animals- perhaps the tread title is misleading- ok it IS misleading.
 
  • #38
_Mayday_ said:
Can hookers afford real fur? I just thought it was Rapper Pimps hoes who managed to get the fur and still live a hooker like lifestyle.

LOL! Do you know of any other job that pays between 100-1000 dollars an hour? at least that's what I heard. Not admitting to anything here.
 
  • #39
So should we also take a stand against silk? Any idea how many millions cacoons are boiled alive in the process?
 
  • #40
Andre said:
So should we also take a stand against silk? Any idea how many millions cacoons are boiled alive in the process?

none. they aren't alive in first place. the little worms inside are a different story
 
  • #41
Andre said:
So should we also take a stand against silk? Any idea how many millions cacoons are boiled alive in the process?

Yeah, caterpillars are cute and fuzzy too! :biggrin: The distinctions seem rather arbitrary, don't they? How do they think those poor soybean plants feel as they are having their ovaries ripped out without anesthetic just so the vegans can have tofu.
 
  • #42
russ_watters said:
Agreed. I much prefer leather (for men and women).

Agreed.

http://www.mtv.com/news/images/archive/Village_People/sq-village-people-leather-uni.gif

tribdog said:
LOL! Do you know of any other job that pays between 100-1000 dollars an hour? at least that's what I heard. Not admitting to anything here.

I've never heard of anything worse to waste your money on. They have never stiked me as particularily well off to be honest, maybe they spend their money on other things.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #43
Everybody sing...! It's fun to stay at the YMCA...!
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
2K
Replies
27
Views
5K
  • · Replies 31 ·
2
Replies
31
Views
4K
Replies
17
Views
7K
  • · Replies 29 ·
Replies
29
Views
3K
  • · Replies 80 ·
3
Replies
80
Views
11K
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 45 ·
2
Replies
45
Views
6K
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
19
Views
7K