kmp
- 14
- 0
what is the difference between insulators and dielectrics?:
The discussion revolves around the distinctions between insulators and dielectrics, exploring their definitions, properties, and contexts of use. Participants engage in a technical examination of the terms, considering both fundamental and practical perspectives.
Participants generally disagree on the equivalence of insulators and dielectrics, with multiple competing views presented regarding their definitions and properties. The discussion remains unresolved, with no consensus reached.
The discussion highlights the ambiguity in terminology and the importance of context when discussing materials classified as insulators or dielectrics. Some participants note that the differences may be subtle and often overlooked in practical applications.
f95toli said:I disagree. it is correct to say that all dielectrics are insulators; but there are insulators that are not (usually) referred to as dielectrics.
A good example would be Mott insulators (I can also think of other examples, e.g. metallic superinsulators).
Note the "usually" above, I have heard of people referring to Mott insulators as dielectrics; but it is pretty uncommon and there is a case for reserving the word "dielectric" for materials which are insulating due to their band structure.
Gokul43201 said:I also disagree with the equivalence for somewhat pedantic reasons. While the terms are almost always used interchangeably in the field, they refer to different underlying electronic properties. A good insulator is therefore a material with low conductivity while a good dielectric is a material with high polarizability. Of course, a dielectric used in a capacitive role is almost always preferred when it also has lower conductivity.