Discussion Overview
The discussion explores the types and levels of mathematics utilized across various social science fields, including economics, sociology, psychology, anthropology, and geography. Participants share insights on the mathematical tools and theories that are relevant to these disciplines, as well as the variability in mathematical training required for practitioners.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Conceptual clarification
Main Points Raised
- Some participants note that statistics are commonly used in economics and sociology, with one mentioning plans to take a statistics course.
- Others highlight the use of dynamical systems theory in analyzing social phenomena, such as the arms race.
- A participant suggests that advanced mathematical concepts like feedback systems, randomness, and optimization are important for modeling in social sciences, though they acknowledge that significant work is needed to understand real-world situations.
- One post discusses a "movement" in social sciences that incorporates Bayesian mathematics and various programming languages, suggesting a shift towards more applied mathematics.
- It is noted that finance employs high-level mathematics, including stochastic calculus, to model stock markets, although the effectiveness of these models for predictions is questioned.
- Cluster analysis is mentioned as a fundamental tool in social sciences, particularly for discussing groups or classifications.
- Some participants express skepticism about the predictive power of stochastic calculus in finance, suggesting it is more about generating workable models than making accurate predictions.
- Economics is described as highly mathematical, utilizing tools such as linear algebra, differential equations, and game theory, while geography is noted for its use of advanced mathematics like tensor algebra.
- There is a contrast drawn between fields like anthropology, which may use little to no math, and others like psychology and sociology, which require statistical knowledge.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally agree that the level of mathematics used in social sciences varies significantly by discipline. However, there are multiple competing views on the specific types of mathematics employed and their effectiveness in modeling and prediction, leaving the discussion unresolved on several points.
Contextual Notes
The discussion reflects a range of assumptions about the applicability and effectiveness of various mathematical methods in social sciences, with some claims depending on specific contexts or definitions that are not fully explored.