Discussion Overview
The discussion centers around identifying an appropriate constitutive law for modeling crack propagation in high-density polyethylene (HDPE) using Ansys. It explores the behavior of HDPE under large deformations, particularly in the context of tensile testing and potential crystallization during crack formation.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Mathematical reasoning
Main Points Raised
- One participant inquires about the size of strains and the possibility of crystallization during crack formation.
- Another participant notes that HDPE can experience large strains, up to 600%, during tensile tests, and mentions that crack propagation occurs at room temperature.
- A participant expresses that developing a general constitutive equation for HDPE at large deformations is challenging and questions whether a simplified quantification of the kinematics is possible.
- Some participants reference authors who propose that the constitutive law for HDPE is elastic-viscoplastic, while raising concerns about determining the parameters for the viscoplastic part, which requires specific experimental data.
- Others mention that some authors classify the constitutive law as elastic-plastic and question its appropriateness for HDPE.
- One participant highlights the existence of various constitutive equations for viscoelastic materials but notes the lack of a model that quantitatively describes HDPE behavior for arbitrary deformations.
- A participant suggests using the Perzyna model to simulate the viscoplastic behavior of HDPE and seeks information on its applicability to large versus small deformations.
- Another participant admits unfamiliarity with the Perzyna model and cannot provide information on its effectiveness.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express differing views on the appropriate constitutive law for HDPE, with some advocating for elastic-viscoplastic models and others for elastic-plastic models. The discussion remains unresolved regarding which model is most suitable.
Contextual Notes
Participants highlight the challenges in determining material parameters for viscoplastic models and the potential discrepancies between laboratory measurements and field conditions, which may affect model accuracy.