Moonbear
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 11,919
- 54
shamrock5585 said:instead of everybody complaining can we ask... qman do you understand how this is obtained?
And if s/he answers "yes?" Let the OP work through the problem themselves with hints and tips from the Homework Helpers, not outright answers. The purpose of this forum is not to make sure everyone has the right answers on their homeworks, but to make sure they've learned HOW they arrived at that answer and fully understand the subject so they can solve problems on their own. Handing an answer out doesn't accomplish that, neither does asking someone a yes/no question if they understand (some students do not realize they don't fully understand if they have an answer and can work backward since they haven't had a chance to work without that crutch). Let them SHOW you they understand by putting their own work into the problem.
Since there have now been TWO attempts from different people to give out an answer/complete solution here, this is an official notice from the staff letting folks know that we do NOT permit giving out complete answers.
Sorry to qman that your thread has been so disrupted.