mersecske
- 186
- 0
Which is the asteroid size or mass
which can destroy the Earth totally
(I mean, breaking apart)?
which can destroy the Earth totally
(I mean, breaking apart)?
The discussion centers around the concept of binding energy in relation to the potential for an asteroid impact to completely shatter the Earth. Participants explore the theoretical implications of asteroid size and mass required for such an event, as well as the energy calculations involved. The conversation includes both real-world considerations and hypothetical scenarios involving imaginary planets.
Participants express differing views on the feasibility of an asteroid completely shattering the Earth, with some agreeing on the binding energy calculations while others remain skeptical about the practical implications. The discussion does not reach a consensus on the conditions under which an asteroid impact could lead to total destruction.
Participants reference the binding energy required to break the Earth apart, but the discussion lacks clarity on the assumptions behind the energy calculations and the definitions of terms used, such as "shatter" and "break apart." There are also unresolved questions about the size and mass of asteroids in relation to hypothetical scenarios.
mersecske said:Back to the asteroids and Earth.
My question is not about real world.
So let's see an imagenary planet, maybe smaller than Earth.
Asteroids usually cause only small demage on the surface,
but a real big one can brake the planet apart.
Maybe the size of the asteroid is comparable to the planet,
but my question is that it can be order of magnitude smaller or not?
mersecske said:What is
"ryan_m_b's binding energy of 2.23e32 J"
?
Vagn said:The binding energy that ryan_m_b talked about before.
The potential energy keeping Earth together is 2.23x1032 joules, which means you fully break Earth apart, you would need to supply that amount of energy to the Earth.