What is the necessary and sufficient condition?
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
34 replies · 4K views
Physics news on Phys.org
Science Advisor
- 929
- 1,226
Ok, the implication is still false and the same counter-example works, but I should go back to primary school, because elementary arithmetic is, at times, an impossible task. It should be for ## a=1##nuuskur said:f you pick, say, ## a=1##, then the implication
[tex] (x+2)(x-5)<0 \implies -1<x<3[/tex]
is false. We can pick ##x = -1.5##, it still stands that ##(x+2)(x-5)<0 ##, but at the same time ##x\leq -1##.
[tex] (x+2)(x-5)<0 \implies 1<x<3[/tex]
Now, any ##x\in (-2,1]\cup [3,5) ## works as a counter-example.
but I am certain now that this is correct

Last edited:
Helly123
- 581
- 20
Ok thanksnuuskur said:Ok, the implication is still false and the same counter-example works, but I should go back to primary school, because elementary arithmetic is, at times, an impossible task. It should be for ## a=1##
[tex] (x+2)(x-5)<0 \implies 1<x<3[/tex]
Now, any ##x\in (-2,1]\cup [3,5) ## works as a counter-example.
but I am certain now that this is correct
![]()
Homework Helper
- 1,047
- 337
I'm still hung up on the original problem statement which says x2 − 3x − 10 < 10. Did we decide somewhere that this was in error?SammyS said:Yes.
For | x − 2 | < a to be a sufficient condition so that x2 − 3x − 10 < 0, the range for a is 0 < a ≤ 3.
You have not been very clear in showing that this is the case.
This does not give all of the values of x which satisfy the given quadratic inequality. Rather any x fulfilling | x − 2 | < a will satisfy the quadratic inequality.for the specified range of a values. So being in that interval is a sufficient condition for x to satisfy the quadratic inequality..
Helly123
- 581
- 20
Yes. I made mistake. It supposed to be x^2 - 3x - 10 < 0tnich said:I'm still hung up on the original problem statement which says x2 − 3x − 10 < 10. Did we decide somewhere that this was in error?
Similar threads
Necessary and sufficient condition for equation and inequality
- songoku
- · Replies 4 ·
- Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
- Replies
- 4
Necessary and sufficient condition for inequality
- songoku
- · Replies 15 ·
- Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
- Replies
- 15
Undergrad A sufficient condition for integrability of equation ##\nabla g=0##
- Jianbing_Shao
- · Replies 71 ·
- Special and General Relativity
- Replies
- 71
When can two 2D vectors form a basis for the plane?
- PcumP_Ravenclaw
- · Replies 6 ·
- Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
- Replies
- 6
Graduate Necessary and sufficient condition for an electron to radiat
- qnach
- · Replies 3 ·
- Electromagnetism
- Replies
- 3
Graduate Necessary and sufficient condition for differentiability
- Local
- · Replies 6 ·
- Calculus
- Replies
- 6
Range of value to satisfy sufficient and necessary condition
- songoku
- · Replies 3 ·
- Precalculus Mathematics Homework Help
- Replies
- 3
Necessary and Sufficient Meaning of Isometries by D. J. H. Garling
- Math Amateur
- · Replies 5 ·
- Topology and Analysis
- Replies
- 5
Undergrad Sufficient Conditions for a Covering Space
- Euge
- · Replies 1 ·
- Math Problem of the Week
- Replies
- 1
State and prove a necessary and sufficient condition on $\alpha, \beta \in F$ so that $F(\sqrt{\alpha})=F(\sqrt{\beta})
- Chris L T521
- · Replies 1 ·
- Math Problem of the Week
- Replies
- 1