What is the proof for Bertrand's theorem in celestial mechanics?

  • Thread starter Thread starter cristianbahena
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Proof Theorem
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
1 reply · 2K views
cristianbahena
Messages
16
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
I don't know how I can find the equation (2.78) and the next equations. It is from Classical Dynamics: A Contemporary Approach: Jorge V.
Relevant Equations
integral equation of energy (central problem)
Screenshot at 2019-10-06 10-13-25.png
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Usually you will start from ##\mathcal{L} = \frac{1}{2}\mu v^2 - V## and then write\begin{align*}
\frac{1}{2}\mu v^2 + V &= E \\

\frac{1}{2} \mu (\dot{r}^2 + r^2\dot{\varphi}^2) + V(r) &= E
\end{align*}Also ##\varphi## doesn't appear in the Lagrangian so ##\partial \mathcal{L} / \partial \dot{\varphi} = \mu r^2 \dot{\varphi} := L## is conserved, so you can replace ##\tilde{V}(r) := \frac{1}{2} \mu r^2 \dot{\varphi}^2 + V(r) = \dfrac{L^2}{2\mu r^2} + V(r)##. Further, write ##\dot{r} = \dfrac{dr}{d\varphi} \dot{\varphi} = \dfrac{dr}{d\varphi} \dfrac{L}{\mu r^2}## so that\begin{align*}
\frac{L^2}{2\mu^2 r^4} \left( \dfrac{dr}{d\varphi} \right)^2 + \tilde{V}(r) = E
\end{align*}which is simple to invert to the integral\begin{align*}

\varphi(r) = \sqrt{\frac{L^2}{2\mu}} \int^r \frac{dr}{r^2\sqrt{E - \tilde{V}(r)}}

\end{align*}The classic substitution is now ##u=1/r##, which transforms this into\begin{align*}

\tilde{\varphi}(u) = -\sqrt{\frac{L^2}{2\mu}} \int^{u} \frac{du}{\sqrt{E - \tilde{W}(u)}}

\end{align*}Of course we can also take the integral between the minimum and maximum ##u## of the orbit, and using the scaling ##u = yu_{\mathrm{max}}## given in the image the integral becomes\begin{align*}

\Theta := \varphi(r_{\mathrm{max}}) - \varphi(r_{\mathrm{min}}) = \sqrt{\frac{L^2}{2\mu}} \int_{v_{\mathrm{min}}}^1 \frac{u_{\mathrm{max}} dy}{\sqrt{E - \tilde{U}(y)}}

\end{align*}You should notice that since ##\tilde{V}(r) = \dfrac{L^2}{2\mu r^2} + V(r)##, that ##\tilde{W}(u) = \dfrac{L^2 u^2}{2\mu } + V\left(\dfrac{1}{u} \right)##. If we let ##V(r) = \alpha r^k## then ##\tilde{W}(u) = \dfrac{L^2 u^2}{2\mu } + \alpha u^{-k}##. Finally when we substitute for ##y## we see that\begin{align*}
\tilde{U}(y) = \dfrac{L^2 y^2 u_{\mathrm{max}}^2}{2\mu } + \alpha u_{\mathrm{max}}^{-k} y^{-k} = y^2 u_{\mathrm{max}}^2 \left( \dfrac{L^2 }{2\mu } + \alpha (yu_{\mathrm{max}})^{-(k+2)}\right) = u_{\mathrm{max}}^2 \mathcal{Y}(y)
\end{align*}Furthermore ##u_{\mathrm{max}}^2 \mathcal{Y}(1) = \dfrac{L^2 u_{\mathrm{max}}^2}{2\mu} + \alpha (u_{\mathrm{max}})^{-k} = E## is just the energy evaluated at the minimum radius, hence\begin{align*}
\Theta = \sqrt{\frac{L^2}{2\mu}} \int_{v_{\mathrm{min}}}^1 \frac{dy}{\sqrt{\mathcal{Y}(1) - \mathcal{Y}(y)}}
\end{align*}Although I can't comment on the line at the very end of the proof without seeing "equation (2.77)", hope it's somewhat helpful.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71 and hutchphd