What is the solution to the absurd dilatation problem?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DaTario
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary
The discussion revolves around a problem involving two wires made of different materials with distinct coefficients of linear dilatation, where the goal is to determine their lengths summing to 2 meters. The key issue is that while the formalism provides specific lengths, it fails to account for the non-uniqueness of solutions when temperature changes are considered, as both materials will expand or contract differently. Participants emphasize that the initial lengths must be calculated for a specific temperature to maintain the total length invariant, leading to a unique solution at that temperature. However, they also argue that variations in temperature can yield different proportions that still satisfy the total length condition. Ultimately, the conversation highlights the complexities of applying theoretical models to real-world scenarios involving thermal expansion.
  • #31
under basic ideas, onthology properties of the concepts are hidden to many.