What time did they both set off?

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
3 replies · 2K views
GoghAway

Homework Statement


Willy leaves point A and Milly leaves point B, both of them are heading toward each other's starting point. They both have constant speeds, but Milly is faster, and they pass each other at noon without stopping. Milly arrives at point A at 1:00 pm, and Willy arrives at point B at 2:15 pm. At what time did they both set off?

Homework Equations


v = d / t
v = (d2 - d1) / (t2 - t1)

The Attempt at a Solution


I'm putting the data here because it's what I think the problem is telling me, but I know I could be wrong.

Willy
d = D
v = Vw
t = (14.25 hours - t1)

Vw = D / (14.25 h - t1)

Milly
d = D
v = Vm
t = (13.0 hours - t1)

Vm = D / (13.0 h - t1)

After noon
Willy
d = (D - d1)
v = Vw
t = 2.25 hours

Vw = (D - d1) / 2.25 h

Milly
d = d1
v = Vm
t = 1 hour

Vm = d1 / (1 h)

Since Milly is going faster noon, or when they meet would be after the midpoint between point A and B for her, and before the midpoint for Willy.

Since Willy's velocity is always the same:
D/(14.25 h - t1) = (D - d1)/2.25 h
D (2.25 h) = (D - d1)(14.25 h - t1)
D = ((D - d1)(14.25 h - t1)) / (2.25 h)

Since Milly's velocity is always the same:
D/(13.0 h - t1) = d1/(1 h)
D (1 h) = d1 (13.0 h - t1)
D = (d1 (13.0 h - t1)) / (1 h)
d1= (D (1 h)) / (13.0 h - t1)


I'm not sure whether I can sub what D = or what d1 = from what I have since Willy's velocity is always the same with what I have since Milly's velocity is always the same or vice versa. Either way, I don't think I know enough of the unknowns to come up with a numerical value as an answer, but I don't know how to get the information that I need.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Welcome to PF.

Your method will work. You have gotten to the two equations

D = ((D - d1)(14.25 h - t1)) / (2.25 h)

d1= (D (1 h)) / (13.0 h - t1)

It looks like you have two equations with three unknowns. But see what happens if you substitute the expression for d1 of the second equation into the first equation.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: GoghAway
I believe we are given that they both set off at the same time.
 
Thank you TSny! I did as you suggested, and checked the times to see if both Milly and Willy had the correct amount of time after they meet at noon so they would arrive at the correct times, which they did!