Whats the ground breaking research done about sense of time ?

In summary: As far as i can see time can't be sensed..right ?We do have a biological clock which has some feeling of time... It's not very reliable though (consider putting someone in a dark empty room), so it kind of depends on our other senses (vision in particular, probably). But that's not my cup of tea, so I'll shut up about this :smile:In summary, CompuChimp argues that time can't be sensed, space is just three scalars, and that a child born with the ability to sense time would
  • #1
heman
361
0
Hiii All (:) )

It feels nice to be back here...

I have got questions about time...

--Whats the ground breaking research done about sense of time ?
As far as i can see time can't be sensed..right ?
we have got 5 senses but all those senses seem incapable at sensing it..where as on the other hand space can be sensed by vision..etc ..right ?
So i want to ask ..since both are called fundamental..then why does space gets advantage ?
I mean time is considered to be scalar whereas we are thinking of space in upto 11 dimensions..right ?

And the information which i am primarily looking for is Conceptualisation of time from the prespective of linguistics ?

I cudnt find great papers on this topic which talk about temporal sense .. Please pour some light..
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I don't know about perception / sensing of time, but I wanted to correct two of your remarks:
since both are called fundamental..then why does space gets advantage ?
In 'modern' physical theories such as relativity, time and space are actually entangled; you can for example arrange to move "slower" in a time direction by moving faster in a spatial direction.

I mean time is considered to be scalar whereas we are thinking of space in upto 11 dimensions..right ?
Normally we are thinking of space in 3 dimensions, and time in one. If you want, space is also just three scalars. In some theories, it turns out to be a good idea to think of space and time connected in a 4-dimensional space-time, in which there is no separate "time" and "space" (you can define a pure timelike dimension for one observer, but that will be a mix of space and time for another).
For 11 dimensions, I assume you are referring to string theory (there are also variants with up to 26), I think they are actually spacetime dimensions (and I'm also not sure they are all space-like, I heard things like 4 time-dimensions and 6 or 7 space-dimensions)...

As far as i can see time can't be sensed..right ?
Also, we do have a biological clock which has some feeling of time...
It's not very reliable though (consider putting someone in a dark empty room), so it kind of depends on our other senses (vision in particular, probably). But that's not my cup of tea, so I'll shut up about this :smile:
 
  • #3
Hey CompuChimp..interesting name:smile:

CompuChip said:
Normally we are thinking of space in 3 dimensions, and time in one. If you want, space is also just three scalars.

Compu..space can we in both positive or negative direction..but time is always supposed to be positive..right ?


CompuChip said:
Also, we do have a biological clock which has some feeling of time...

I would say a messed up clock..which shows huge variation when we are engrossed in something and when we are heavily bored..in engrossed case we want time to stay whereas in bored case we want it to pass..
and i will like to pass this question to others too..
Does a child who is born also has this biological clock ? If i try to guess, child is also able to order events..right ? child can say what came first and what came next..how does a child do that ..child must be storing that in memory..and for that transition it got to have a sense of time..so is child born with that ability to sense time ?
 
  • #4
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #5
Hiii CaptainQuasar...thats an interesting article i would say..But i really am not able to get the link between questions i have asked and point this article depicts..perhaps you would like to elaborate a bit..
 
  • #6
Oh, there isn't a direct link. Like I said it's tangential to the topic. I just thought you might find it interesting since you're thinking about perception of time.
 
  • #7
heman said:
It feels nice to be back here...

It's nice to have you back, my friend. :smile:
"Time is Nature's way of keeping everything from happening at once."
I believe that the quote is attributable to John Lennon, but I'm frequently confused by things like that.
From a matter of either linguistics or perception, time is a human construct. **** happens, and it happens in accordance with Thermodynamics, but our perception of it varies. As Einstein once said when trying to explain Relativity to a reporter... one minute sitting on a hot stove is a lot longer than one minute sitting on a pretty girl's lap. (I didn't put that in quotes because I'm not certain of the exact wording.)
In any event, our perception is enchanced by time-keeping mechanisms. Medievial nobility were delighted that their hour-glasses told them within half an hour or so of what time it was. I'm irritated that my watch is over a minute slow, and W (who gave it to me for X-mas) tossed the manual so I can't reset it. And perish forbid the wrath of an astronomer or particle physicist who finds that a cesium clock is off by a picosecond! :eek:
 
  • #8
heman said:
As far as i can see time can't be sensed..right ?
we have got 5 senses but all those senses seem incapable at sensing it..where as on the other hand space can be sensed by vision..etc ..right ?
"The five senses" is just a popularization. We have dozens, at the very least, and one of them is, in fact, a sense of time.
 
  • #9
heman said:
I would say a messed up clock..
As a musician, I'm insulted! My internal clock does, of course, have some limitations, but for some tasks, it has milisecond precision!
 
  • #10
russ_watters said:
As a musician, I'm insulted! My internal clock does, of course, have some limitations, but for some tasks, it has milisecond precision!

Russ's sense of time may actually be even more precise than his fashion sense. :-p
 
  • #11
CaptainQuasar said:
Russ's sense of time may actually be even more precise than his fashion sense. :-p

A tree sloth with a paint brush would be more precise than Russ' fashion sense. He's a bloody engineer... think 'Dilbert' with a closet. :rolleyes:
 
  • #12
russ_watters said:
"The five senses" is just a popularization. We have dozens, at the very least, and one of them is, in fact, a sense of time.

-- heyee Russ...please enlighten abt these more senses if you can..can this IR be a sense..i mean detecting infra red...
 
  • #13
Danger said:
It's nice to have you back, my friend. :smile:

Yo Danger!:smile: ... pleasure to see you and even greator pleasure to read ur words...


Danger said:
"Time is Nature's way of keeping everything from happening at once."
I believe that the quote is attributable to John Lennon, but I'm frequently confused by things like that.
From a matter of either linguistics or perception, time is a human construct.

a human construct...u mean it doesn't exist for animals or other creatures..something of that sort...

Danger said:
**** happens, and it happens in accordance with Thermodynamics, but our perception of it varies.

i think time also represents cause-effect sense...when u say thermodynamics here Danger...do u mean going in direction of increasing entropy or something more specific u had in mind...
 
  • #14
russ_watters said:
As a musician, I'm insulted!

Dint mean to...i respect musicians as much as i respect scientists..Both scientist and musician's passion are motivated by same reason..to feel beauty in their own visions of world..

russ_watters said:
My internal clock does, of course, have some limitations, but for some tasks, it has milisecond precision!

hmmm..what might be the reason of that preciseness Russ ?
do u have that since childhood or out of practise ?


_________________

Guys,,Does anyone knows about the good research done in field of perception of time..or can give me pointers to how to go about it ?
 
  • #15
heman said:
a human construct...u mean it doesn't exist for animals or other creatures..something of that sort...



i think time also represents cause-effect sense...when u say thermodynamics here Danger...do u mean going in direction of increasing entropy or something more specific u had in mind...

That's exactly what I was referring to. As for the animals, I didn't mean to imply that time doesn't apply to them. What I meant was that the units of time are a human construct. I think that any semi-sentient animal has some sense of cause & effect, even if it's purely instinctual. Hunger--eat--not hungry--take a dump--sleep--hunger... Humans are the only species that I know of who quantify time. Lucy definitely has some intrinsic sense of it, since she will wake me up on my day off if I'm not mobile when my alarm would go off on a work day. That actually saved my ass one day when I slept through my alarm.
 

Related to Whats the ground breaking research done about sense of time ?

1. What is the current understanding of the sense of time in the scientific community?

The current understanding is that the sense of time is a complex phenomenon that involves multiple factors such as memory, attention, and perception. It is still not fully understood and is an active area of research.

2. How do researchers study the sense of time?

Researchers use a variety of methods such as psychophysical experiments, brain imaging techniques, and computational models to study the sense of time. These methods allow for a better understanding of the neural mechanisms and processes involved in time perception.

3. What groundbreaking research has been done in the field of time perception?

Some groundbreaking research in this field includes the discovery of specialized brain regions for time perception, the role of neurotransmitters in time perception, and the influence of emotions and attention on time perception.

4. How does the sense of time differ among individuals?

The sense of time can vary among individuals due to factors such as age, culture, and neurological conditions. Some individuals may have a faster or slower perception of time, while others may experience time more accurately.

5. What practical applications can be derived from research on the sense of time?

Research on the sense of time has practical applications in fields such as psychology, neuroscience, and education. It can also help in the development of interventions for individuals with time-related disorders, such as ADHD or Parkinson's disease.

Similar threads

  • General Discussion
Replies
10
Views
889
  • Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
Replies
0
Views
323
  • General Discussion
Replies
4
Views
781
Replies
13
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
1
Views
996
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
0
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
935
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
11
Views
2K
Back
Top