Why Are Wollaston Prisms So Expensive and What Are the Alternatives?

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter Flavio
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Prism
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

Wollaston prisms, particularly those made from high-quality calcite, are priced between €450-700 due to the expensive raw materials and intricate manufacturing processes involved, including cutting, polishing, and assembling the crystals. Defects in the crystals, such as bubbles and optical inhomogeneity, further contribute to the high costs by degrading performance. Alternatives like Rochon prisms may offer a more affordable solution, but they may not meet specific requirements such as having both beams exit from the same face. For budget-conscious buyers, exploring different grades of prisms or contacting manufacturers directly may yield more affordable options.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of optical components and their functions
  • Familiarity with polarization techniques in optics
  • Knowledge of crystal defects and their impact on optical performance
  • Basic principles of prism design and manufacturing processes
NEXT STEPS
  • Research "Rochon prisms" as a cost-effective alternative to Wollaston prisms
  • Explore "optical crystal defects" and their effects on performance
  • Investigate "different grades of calcite prisms" available in the market
  • Learn about "polarization beam splitters" and their operational principles
USEFUL FOR

Optical engineers, physicists, and researchers in optics looking for cost-effective solutions for polarization applications and those interested in the manufacturing intricacies of optical components.

Flavio
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
I would like to buy a calcite Wollaston prism, but they are priced €450-700 for 10x10mm to 14x14mm prisms (plus €150 for "broadband antireflection coating") which means way beyond my budget. I was wondering why are these objects that expensive? I have asked the same question to two different manufacturers; one did not reply, the second told be "because of raw materials".
The best I have found over the Internet is a sentence in this paper http://authors.library.caltech.edu/6948/1/SANrsi05.pdf which is "Wollaston prisms are expensive due to the large optical quality crystals required for their fabrication."

Do you know more details to explain the high price?
Do you have any idea on how I could replace a Wollaston prism with something cheaper (and which accomplishes the same task)?

Thank you
 
Science news on Phys.org
Does £26.00 make it affordable?
Google for "polarisation beam splitters - cheap!".
You just looked for quotes for too proffessional devices ...
 
Last edited:
Thank you xts, £26 would be ok but I am specifically looking for Wollaston-like prisms. My problem is that commercially-cheap polarization beam splitters work by internal reflection, therefore the 2 outgoing rays exit from 2 different faces of the prism. What I need instead, is the 2 divergent rays exit from the same face.
To make my problem more clear, you may look at 2 different representations here
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glan–Taylor_prism
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wollaston_prism

I have found a potentially interesting article here http://www.opticsinfobase.org/abstract.cfm?uri=ao-47-3-328 where they use "a polycarbonate prism under mechanical loading", but unfortunately it is not free and I do not have access to it.

Thank you again
 
The high price comes from cutting, polishing and assembling crystals to the required specifications.

Why exactly do you need both beams to exit the same facet? If you give us more detail, perhaps we can come up with a workaround?

Claude.
 
Flavio said:
Do you know more details to explain the high price?
Do you have any idea on how I could replace a Wollaston prism with something cheaper (and which accomplishes the same task)?

Thank you

The crystals are dug out of the ground, and in order to get high performance, the crystals have to have very few defects:

"Defects in bulk calcite are characterized by bubbles (presence of randomly scattered bubbles vary from relatively large to small sizes and fine bubble lines), striae (streaks of sudden variation of refractive index which can be detected interferometrically ), optical inhomogeneity (gradual variation of refractive index in bulk material ) and stress birefringence (variation of birefringence in bulk material due to defective growth of the crystal ). These defects cause degradation of polarization and transmission loss due to scattering and absorption." (from Karl Lambrecht's site, see below)

Plus, as Claude mentioned, the manufacturing steps are not inexpensive, either.

Karl Lambrecht (http://www.klccgo.com/) lists different grades, there may be something in your price range.

But in any case, as Claude asked- why do you need both beams to exit the same face? There are Rochon prisms that may be less expensive. What other specifications do you require- power levels, extinction ratios, beam deviations, acceptance angles, etc.
 
Hi guys, we have developed 20x20x20mm un-mounted Wollaston prisms with calcite.
We are a Singapore company, if any interest, pls email me:
charles.chen@photonik.com.sg