I wanted to add to a previous thread regarding the placement of commas every third digit in our decimal system. Unfortunately, the thread was closed, so I am creating a new thread to mention my pet theory about this practice.(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

The question is why we choose to place commas every third digit. The simple answer is for ease of readability. This of course begs the question, why not group together digits in sets of 4 or 5 (as we do with tally marks, for instance?) Why 3 specifically?

Some argue that answer has some sort of physiological basis in how our brains process information. I propose a more elegant -- and I think more appealing -- explanation. It boils down to the fact that we have 3 spatial dimensions in our universe (or, at least, 3 that we directly perceive).

Begin with the observation that we have ten fingers on which to count, and this is why we use a base 10 numeral system. If we want to count more than ten but less than one hundred objects, we use two digits, the first indicating the number of groupings of ten (tens place), and the second indicating the remaining ungrouped objects (units place).

Translate, then, this simple counting method into its visual analog.

First suppose we have 7 identical cubes. Since we can count the cubes on our fingers, we simply line them up in a row, in the positive direction along the x-axis, for instance. Done.

Next suppose we have 57 identical cubes. We arrange them into five rows of ten (each row oriented in the positive x-direction again), but side by side (so successive rows are stacked along the positive y-direction), followed by an incomplete row of seven. The digit 5 represents the number of complete rows, and the digit 7 represents the number of cubes leftover.

Further, suppose we want to count 100 identical small cubes. The natural procedure is to arrange the cubes into 10 rows of 10, creating a "square of cubes" that roughly sits in the x-y plane. Following the conventions of early childhood education, I will call this grouping of 100 a "flat." So far so good.

Further, suppose we want to count 357 cubes. To organize these cubes, we first organize three "flats" of one hundred cubes each; we stack these three high along the z-axis in the positive direction. On top of these three flats, we place 5 rows of 10 each, and finally the seven remaining cubes in an incomplete row.

To count one thousand such cubes, we stack 10 flats in the xy plane on top of each other. Done.

But now comes the trick. What if we want to count seven thousand one hundred such cubes? You might suggest that we simply stack seventy flats on top of each other. This seems a decent arrangement, but the problem is that we can only count up to ten objects at a time before abstracting before abstracting into "rows" or "flats" or other groupings. We simply can't count to seventy directly. It is natural, then, that we must now construct a new abstraction of one thousand small cubes, which we will call simply a "10^3 cube." Following our convention, in which we have made a 90 degree turn in our stacking process at each power of ten, we now stack seven 10^3 cubes in the positive x direction in order to count seven thousand.

That is to say, we have begun the process over again, since we starting by arranging unit cubes in the positive x-direction. This process of abstracting a group of one thousand cubes into a single cube, then continuing to count along the x, y, and z axes will repeat indefinitely. Every time we abstract a thousand cubes into a single cube and starting building in the positive x-direction again, we place a comma to indicate the abstraction and repetition. This happens every third power of ten because we have three spatial dimensions in which to count.

Anyone like my pet theory?

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

# Why commas are placed every third digit

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**