kyphysics
- 684
- 445
It's not wrong to short squeeze in the markets, as it happens all the time. Hedge funds do it to each other when they smell blood from a vulnerable position. Big institutional investors can do it to the entire market of shorts if they want to as well (just push up all the indexes). "Hurt" would be considered what naturally happens in any of these transactions.russ_watters said:My understanding is part of the motivation of the redditors is to harm the hedge funds(which they did). I think it's fair to call that an attack. I'm not sure what else to call it. Competition? Maybe, but in managing my portfolio, what good/harm I'm doing to other investors never enters my head.
The part that does seem illegal potentially is market manipulation via collusion to do this. That's why these Redditers are saying, "We like the stock." They are saying they just want to buy it for its own sake to deny they are colluding to short squeeze big hedge fund shorts.
As far as I can tell, it's the outright collusion that would be illegal market manipulation - not short squeezing, which is perfectly legal. Mark Cuban - not saying I agree with him - had some interesting comments, Russ:
Any thoughts on his take?