Why Do Astrophysicists Use νLν in Accretion Disk Emission Studies?

7 replies · 3K views · last reply
Astroiaco
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Why in Astrophysics it is used νLν (where ν is the frequency and Lν is the luminosity at that frequency) in the emission spectrum of an accretion disk?
 
Frequency is used to identify nuclei, while luminosity will tell you how much.
 
Ok, but why often in the plot of luminosity (where there are ν in abscissa and ν*Lν in ordinate) there is the product between ν and Lν and not only Lν? I don't know if i explained myself better.
 
Accretion disk are of different scales, depending on the mass of the black hole. But guessing from your profile pic and the similarity of the field I assume you are talking about the supermassive black hole accreting galactic matter; more precisely Active Galactic Nuclei(AGNs).

Astroiaco said:
but why often in the plot of luminosity (where there are ν in abscissa and ν*Lν in ordinate) there is the product between ν and Lν and not only Lν?
Here's why I think it is so: to reduce the graph size!

There's something you missed, sometimes the graph is plotted logarithmically, otherwise in powers of 10. This is because the Spectrum is expected to account for the variations across the whole electromagnetic range, and hence the graph would be too big if plotted in normal units.
Log-log plot of vF_v (erg cm^-2 s^-1) against frequency (Hz) from radio to TeV, showing a double-humped spectral energy distribution with a low-energy peak near 10^17 Hz and a high-energy peak near 10^25 Hz, with a thick instantaneous-spectra curve, a thin average-spectra curve, and data points.


A similar reasoning goes for plotting the product νLν. In log units this is easier to see. Notice that log(νLν)=logν+logLν. Now look at the above graph, a simple subtraction will tell you that the y-axis of the graph scales from -24 to -35 if only logLν is plotted.

Another reason might be by convention. Usually AGNs have a typical double hump(the shapes vary for different sources) structure when plotted as a product. In field they usually fit the different emission mechanics to this double hump structure; not that you can't do this for just luminosity, it's just what they do.

PS: Why I think this can't be from concrete theoretical calculation? Well, it doesn't matter if you plot luminosity or the product of luminosity and frequency, since the only quantity with nontrivial variations is the luminosity. Besides there are options in plotting program to plot ν2Lν.
 
Attachments
  • Log-log plot of vF_v (erg cm^-2 s^-1) against frequency (Hz) from radio to TeV, showing a double-humped spectral energy distribution with a low-energy peak near 10^17 Hz and a high-energy peak near 10^25 Hz, with a thick instantaneous-spectra curve, a thin average-spectra curve, and data points.
    Spectral-energy-distributions-SED-of-the-blazar-PKS-2155-304-during-its-2006-highly.png
    34 KB · Views: 1,197
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Astroiaco
Astroiaco said:
Why in Astrophysics it is used νLν (where ν is the frequency and Lν is the luminosity at that frequency) in the emission spectrum of an accretion disk?

Could you pls provide a reference source? I suspect that ##L_{\nu}## would be a spectral luminosity, i.e. luminosity per an unit frequency interval, measured in units ##(W/Hz)##. By multiplying this value and a specific frequency interval ##\nu##, you should get the total luminosity in Watts over this specific interval.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Astroiaco
lomidrevo said:
Could you pls provide a reference source? I suspect that ##L_{\nu}## would be a spectral luminosity, i.e. luminosity per an unit frequency interval, measured in units ##(W/Hz)##. By multiplying this value and a specific frequency interval ##\nu##, you should get the total luminosity in Watts over this specific interval.
I'm studying the AGNs for my undergraduate thesis, so i have many reference sources, but for example you can find this type of writing on: Dan Maoz "Astrophysics in a Nutshell".

Yes, ##L_{\nu}## is measured in units ##(W/Hz)##.
 
phoenix95 said:
Accretion disk are of different scales, depending on the mass of the black hole. But guessing from your profile pic and the similarity of the field I assume you are talking about the supermassive black hole accreting galactic matter; more precisely Active Galactic Nuclei(AGNs).Here's why I think it is so: to reduce the graph size!

There's something you missed, sometimes the graph is plotted logarithmically, otherwise in powers of 10. This is because the Spectrum is expected to account for the variations across the whole electromagnetic range, and hence the graph would be too big if plotted in normal units.
View attachment 230147

A similar reasoning goes for plotting the product νLν. In log units this is easier to see. Notice that log(νLν)=logν+logLν. Now look at the above graph, a simple subtraction will tell you that the y-axis of the graph scales from -24 to -35 if only logLν is plotted.

Another reason might be by convention. Usually AGNs have a typical double hump(the shapes vary for different sources) structure when plotted as a product. In field they usually fit the different emission mechanics to this double hump structure; not that you can't do this for just luminosity, it's just what they do.

PS: Why I think this can't be from concrete theoretical calculation? Well, it doesn't matter if you plot luminosity or the product of luminosity and frequency, since the only quantity with nontrivial variations is the luminosity. Besides there are options in plotting program to plot ν2Lν.
Thank you very much!
 
Astroiaco said:
I'm studying the AGNs for my undergraduate thesis, so i have many reference sources, but for example you can find this type of writing on: Dan Maoz "Astrophysics in a Nutshell".

Yes, ##L_{\nu}## is measured in units ##(W/Hz)##.

Ah good, I think I found quite a nice explanation in Carroll&Ostlies: "An Introduction to Modern Astrophysics", two snapshots below. If I got it right, when you construct graph like this, the area under the curve of an interval will be proportional to the amount of energy received in that interval (i.e. "equal areas under the graph correspond to equal amounts of energy").

Log-log plot of log10 vF (arbitrary units) against log10 v (Hz) sketching the continuum of many AGNs, showing a radio quiet curve, a radio loud dashed line, a turnover, an IR bump and a big blue bump.


Printed textbook page with the equation L_interval proportional to the integral from nu1 to nu2 of F_nu dnu, equal to the integral of nu F_nu d(ln nu) equals 10 times the integral of nu F_nu d(log10 nu), labelled equation 28.2, followed by explanatory text.
 
Attachments
  • Printed textbook page with the equation L_interval proportional to the integral from nu1 to nu2 of F_nu dnu, equal to the integral of nu F_nu d(ln nu) equals 10 times the integral of nu F_nu d(log10 nu), labelled equation 28.2, followed by explanatory text.
    upload_2018-9-10_8-9-47.png
    21.4 KB · Views: 540
  • Log-log plot of log10 vF (arbitrary units) against log10 v (Hz) sketching the continuum of many AGNs, showing a radio quiet curve, a radio loud dashed line, a turnover, an IR bump and a big blue bump.
    upload_2018-9-10_8-10-58.png
    29.8 KB · Views: 562
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Astroiaco