Why Do Sphere Surface Areas Differ With Same Approximation?

3 replies · 3K views · last reply
joseph_seb
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
i have found the area of sphere in two ways using the same approximation.but i get two different answers ;one the correct value 4∏R^2?how does this happen?
i'm attaching the solution below?please refer to the attachments and give a solution?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten notes deriving the surface area of a sphere by summing frustum bands, with a sketch of a sphere sliced into thin bands and the formula total area = integral of 2 pi R sin theta d theta giving 4 pi R squared.
    spherearea1.jpg
    20.3 KB · Views: 586
  • Handwritten notes titled Method II on a sphere surface area approximation, with a frustum-to-cylinder sketch, a conical strip sketch, the integral of 2πR² sin²θ dθ from 0 to π, and the question why two different areas arise.
    spherearea2.jpg
    17.1 KB · Views: 535


Your mistake is where "transform the frustrum to a cylinder". You don't actually do a "tranformation" you just assume frustrum is equal to the cylinder and that is not true.
 


You write dA = 2Pirh and h = rsin(theta)dtheta, but then you write dA = 2Pir^2 sin^2(theta) dtheta. Where does the extra sin(theta) come from?