Why does electron have wave property

In summary, the conversation discusses the wave-like distribution of a single electron passing through two slits and the role of the slits in this experiment. It also questions the cause and effect behind the wave behavior of particles and the uncertainty principle. The conversation concludes with a suggestion for further reading and a mention of the ongoing debate surrounding the concept of wave function collapse in quantum mechanics.
  • #1
mdeng
68
1
I read that a single electron, when passing two slits, would exhibit wave like distribution on target screen. This makes me wonder about the following.

1) Would this have anything to do with the interference by the slots? I understand that my question may be moot because such interference probably would result in a Gaussian distribution instead of wave-like distributions on the target screen. But still, what's is the role of the slits in this experiment? If we remove the slots, do we still see the wave? If not, why not? If yes, why yes?

2) I believe there must be some cause-effect behind the fact exhibited by the experiment. Classic physics says that an object would not change its momentum unless a force acts upon it. I'd believe this law should still hold in quantum world. So, what is making electron (or any other particles or even daily-life object) behave like a wave? Or is it because the electron is always subject to some intrinsic field (that accompanies any object) which gives it the wave property? What would this field be? If there is no field whatsoever associated, then what's giving the electron its wave property?

Thanks,
- Ming
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
First of all, you cannot observe the "wave like distribution," or interference, with only one electron. The interference pattern emerges statistically, after many electrons have been detected at the screen.

As for question 1), the slits cause the wave interference that produces the pattern at the screen. A single slit would produce a different, gaussian-like pattern.

Question 2) can be answered by considering the uncertainty principle, which describes the non-classical character of momentum, etc.
 
  • #3
country boy said:
First of all, you cannot observe the "wave like distribution," or interference, with only one electron. The interference pattern emerges statistically, after many electrons have been detected at the screen.

What I was referring to was, an experiment where electron is shot to the screen *one by one*, and observation is made after a large number of electrons have been fired. Thus there is no interference between the electrons.

country boy said:
As for question 1), the slits cause the wave interference that produces the pattern at the screen. A single slit would produce a different, gaussian-like pattern.

This is where my question is. If the "wave-like" property relies on the presence of slits, then electrons *themselves* would not possesses a wave property.

country boy said:
Question 2) can be answered by considering the uncertainty principle, which describes the non-classical character of momentum, etc.

You seem to suggest here that wave property of electron (or any other objects) exist without the slits. While I believe this has been proven in experiments, I wonder what gives matter such a property. Where is the cause and effect? It seems to me the uncertainty principle only provides an incomplete model of the world where some parameters are still missing.

- Ming
 
  • #4
Hi Ming,
There are other situations where the wave nature of matter must be used to agree with experiment, so picking on the DS experiment is a mis-targeting.

Getting correct energy levels for the hydrogen atom is one example where wave mechanics is used, but there are no slits.

As for 'why' this is so, I wouldn't like to guess. I recommend 'Inward Bound' by A. Pais which covers how the whole thing came about.
 
  • #5
Hi Mentz,

Thanks for the suggested reading. Regarding the slit experiment, are you suggesting that it’s an invalid proof or can be misleading?

Perhaps, electrons (or anything else) vibrate all the time at a given frequency (wave), that is in a discrete range as Quantum mechanics postulates? I am still very puzzled by the claim by some in Quantum mechanics that such a probabilistic wave makes the electron at anywhere at anytime and then “collapses” instantaneously when being acted up.
 
  • #6
Hi Ming,

I am still very puzzled by the claim by some in Quantum mechanics that such a probabilistic wave makes the electron at anywhere at anytime and then “collapses” instantaneously when being acted up.

This puzzles a lot of people and is the subject of constant debate in this forum and elsewhere. If you search the forum for 'wave function collapse' you'll find many threads discussing foundational and interpretive issues in quantum mechanics.

M
 

1. Why do electrons have wave-like properties?

Electrons have wave-like properties because of their dual nature as both particles and waves. This is known as wave-particle duality, which was first theorized by scientists like Louis de Broglie and confirmed by experiments like the double-slit experiment.

2. How do we know that electrons have wave-like properties?

We know that electrons have wave-like properties because of the results of various experiments, such as the double-slit experiment and the photoelectric effect. These experiments showed that electrons exhibit interference patterns and diffraction, similar to what is seen with waves.

3. What is the significance of electrons having wave-like properties?

The wave-like properties of electrons are significant because they allow us to better understand and describe the behavior of these particles. It also helps to explain phenomena such as quantum tunneling and the uncertainty principle.

4. Can we observe the wave-like properties of electrons?

Yes, we can observe the wave-like properties of electrons through experiments like the double-slit experiment and diffraction experiments. These experiments show that electrons behave like waves and exhibit interference patterns and diffraction.

5. How does the wave-like nature of electrons affect their behavior?

The wave-like nature of electrons affects their behavior in many ways. For example, it allows them to occupy multiple energy levels at once and move through barriers that would otherwise be impossible for a particle. It also explains why electrons are found in specific energy levels around an atom, rather than existing in a continuous range of energies.

Similar threads

  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
36
Views
1K
Replies
23
Views
2K
Replies
28
Views
4K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
22
Views
914
Replies
59
Views
3K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
28
Views
408
Replies
4
Views
805
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
33
Views
2K
Back
Top