Why does shear flow at D equal 29750 instead of 30000?

8 replies · 2K views · last reply
fonseh
Messages
521
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


for shear flow at D , the Q = Ay , i tried another method , i gt 30000 , instead of 29750, why the ans is different from 29750? why can't i use this method( i break the shaded area into 3 parts ( as shown in figure)

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


Q = Ay = (60x10x35) + (2x30x10x150 = 30000[/B]
http://imgur.com/a/VXDK6
 
Attachments
  • Textbook page showing Fig. 7-22d, a cross-section of a thin-walled box beam with dark-shaded rectangles at point D, labeled 5 in., 3.5 in., and 1 in. dimensions, with centerline N-A axis marked.
    7.8.PNG
    61.5 KB · Views: 555
PhanthomJay said:
The author is wrong the Q is 30 in^3 I don't know why you added those zeroes to get 30000
http://imgur.com/a/VXDK6
here' my working , Q = Ay = (60x10x35) + (2x30x10x150) = 30000 , or the author's working 29750 is correct ? which cut is correct ? My cut of section into 3 parts is different from the author's working
, sorry , i posted the wrong notes...here it is
 
Attachments
  • Figure 7-21d: cross-section of a thin-walled rectangular box with three dark-shaded rectangles, labelled 50 mm, 35 mm and 10 mm, with N and A marked on the neutral axis and the area shaded for point D.
    DSC_0034.JPG
    39.4 KB · Views: 539
PhanthomJay said:
Ok then you are correct, good work..
do you mean the author can't cut the beam like this ? why ?
 
Attachments
  • Cross-section of a hollow trapezoidal beam with a 50 mm top flange width, 35 mm depth labelled on the right and inside, neutral axis N-A marked, circled in red.
    f344.png
    75.9 KB · Views: 557
The author cut the beam at the neutral axis to determine Q about the neutral axis, just like you did. But the author messed it up and didn't calculate the areas correctly, what more can I say you are right and they are wrong. Let it be!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: fonseh
PhanthomJay said:
The author cut the beam at the neutral axis to determine Q about the neutral axis, just like you did. But the author messed it up and didn't calculate the areas correctly, what more can I say you are right and they are wrong. Let it be!
no , i am concern about how should the beam be cut ? i divided the beam into 3 parts like this(red) , whereas the author divided the beam into 3 parts like this (green), i gt 30000 , but the author gt 29750 , there's a difference of 250 , which is correct ?
i checked thru the author's my working using calculator , i gt 29750 based on his working
 
Attachments
  • Red diagram of an inverted U-shaped beam: a horizontal top member with two vertical legs, one on each side, dividing the beam into three parts.
    442.png
    934 bytes · Views: 481
  • Diagram of a beam cross-section drawn as a green inverted U shape, with a horizontal top flange and two vertical legs at each end.
    443.png
    1.1 KB · Views: 490
come on now I keep telling you the author made a mistake !

He/she did not use those green areas...they dimensioned incorrectly. The numbers come out to 27500, but the numbers inputted are wrong. The correct ans is 30,000 mm^3.
 
PhanthomJay said:
come on now I keep telling you the author made a mistake !

He/she did not use those green areas...they dimensioned incorrectly. The numbers come out to 27500, but the numbers inputted are wrong. The correct ans is 30,000 mm^3.
sorry , i messed up QC and QD , question solved